The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in English language arts. The lowest is 39% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Ruahmah J Hutchings Elementary
Ruahmah J. Hutchings Elementary sits on Bigelow Road in Howell, the county seat of Livingston County. It is a regular public school serving preschool through fifth grade, part of Howell Public Schools. The enrollment is mid-sized for an elementary building in this area, with a fairly even spread across the grade levels and a sizable kindergarten cohort.
The student body is largely white, with a small share of students identifying as Hispanic, multiracial, Asian, or Black. About a fifth of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is on the lower side for a Michigan public elementary school and reflects the generally comfortable economic profile of the surrounding community. The data does not include counts for students with individualized education programs or English learners, so those pictures are incomplete here.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessments, Hutchings shows a solid academic profile overall. Math proficiency is strongest in third grade, where roughly three in five tested students meet or exceed standards. That share dips in fourth grade and drops further by fifth grade, where fewer than half clear the proficiency bar. English language arts is steadier across the three tested grades, hovering around the midpoint throughout, with fourth grade the strongest. Fifth-grade science matches the ELA pattern, while social studies is the weakest tested subject, with a smaller share of students reaching proficiency. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency index sits just above the median among the districts in Livingston County, which is a reasonably strong position given that the county as a whole tends to perform well. The fifth-grade math slide and the social studies result are the soft spots a parent may want to look into further with the school, particularly as children prepare to transition to middle school.
No state testing data is available for the preschool, kindergarten, first, or second grades, which is expected because Michigan does not test those grades on M-STEP. No graduation rate applies to this school, and chronic absenteeism figures were not reported in the data we reviewed.
Howell itself blends a historic downtown with surrounding residential neighborhoods. Grand River Avenue runs through the center, and the city sits near I-96, giving residents straightforward access to the broader Detroit metro area. Manufacturing is the largest employment sector, with major employers including Thai Summit America Corp and Citizens Insurance, along with the school district and county government. Downtown Howell has preserved much of its historic character, with walkable streets and seasonal events that draw large crowds, including the Michigan Challenge Balloonfest and the Howell Melon Festival. Recent population estimates suggest a slight decline after earlier growth, though the city remains an active civic hub.
The housing market around the school is more expensive than the Michigan baseline and sits just above the national typical home value. Mortgage costs at current rates are substantial, and the affordability gap between renting and owning is narrow, meaning families moving into the area will find neither option cheap. The tradeoff is a community with a defined downtown identity, established schools, and proximity to regional highways.
At the district level, Howell Public Schools has reorganized some of its facilities. The former Southwest Elementary building now houses the Little Highlander's Learning Center alongside Innovation Academy, the district's alternative high school program. That consolidation reflects a shift in how the district uses its buildings, particularly for early learning and alternative pathways, though the available data did not detail broader curriculum or funding changes.
For a family considering Hutchings, the school offers a stable, mostly homogeneous peer environment in a community with a clear civic identity and relatively modest economic need. Academic results are generally above average for the county, with reading holding steady and math strongest in the early grades. A parent weighing this school would do well to ask about how the building supports students as they move from third to fifth grade, especially in math, and what interventions are in place for the transition to middle school.
See more original research from School Decision →