The top reported proficiency rate is 55% in Math. The lowest is 9% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Carter Elementary School
Carter Elementary School sits in the heart of Montrose, a very small city in Genesee County within the Flint metropolitan area. The school serves early grades, pre-kindergarten through fourth, as a regular public school in the Montrose Community Schools district. Its location on Park Street places it near the city's civic core along the M-57 corridor, and the school lot doubles as a community gathering space during the annual Montrose Blueberry Festival, which publicly reported its fiftieth anniversary in 2021. That detail alone tells you something about how woven this school is into the town's fabric.
Academically, the most recent state assessment results come from third grade M-STEP testing. In math, a majority of tested third graders reached proficiency, and in English language arts, a smaller but still substantial share did. When positioned relative to districts in Genesee County, Carter's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades lands in the top quartile. That is a genuinely strong standing for an elementary school serving a community where a substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals. One wrinkle worth naming: the only science result on file dates to an older testing cycle and reflects a very low proficiency rate. Because that result is several years old and Michigan has since changed its science assessment framework, a parent looking at science outcomes may want to ask the school directly what current instruction looks like rather than relying on that stale figure.
The student body is modest in size for its grade band and predominantly white, with small Hispanic and multiracial populations and very few students from other racial groups. Economic need is considerable, with a large portion of the enrollment qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on students with individualized education programs and English learners was not available, so those populations cannot be characterized here. The school's Title I status was also not reported.
Several areas a parent might expect to see are simply absent from the available data. There is no chronic absenteeism figure, no discipline report, no staffing or class-size detail, and no course-access or program information. These gaps are common for elementary schools in smaller districts and do not by themselves signal a problem, but they do mean a family would need to go to the school or district directly for questions about teacher experience, support services, and enrichment offerings.
The surrounding community is auto-oriented and compact. Most residents drive to work, and no public transit system was identified in available sources. Montrose Orchards remains a local landmark, and the city has a traditional small-town layout where civic buildings and schools sit close together rather than on separated campuses. The town's population has been relatively stable, with some sources showing modest growth between census years and others estimating a slight recent decline. No major new housing developments surfaced in public reporting. The housing market in the broader county is active, with listing prices rising and homes moving at a moderate pace. Home values in the school's zip code sit well below both the state and national benchmarks, which points to relatively accessible entry points for families looking to buy, though current mortgage rates shape what that affordability looks like in practice.
At the district level, voters approved a construction bond issue in 2023 to fund additions and renovations across Montrose Community Schools buildings. This continues a publicly reported pattern of bond-funded capital improvements in the district. For families, that means facilities are likely to see continued investment, with the cost reflected in local property taxes over time.
What Carter offers is a small, community-rooted elementary experience with recent proficiency results that stand up well against county peers, set in an affordable, tight-knit town. What it does not offer, at least in the available data, is much visibility into staffing, specialized programs, or student-support services. Families drawn to a place where the school is a civic anchor and where the academic results in the early grades are solid would find a reasonable starting point here, with the understanding that some questions will need to be asked in person rather than answered by the public record.
See more original research from School Decision →