The top reported proficiency rate is 90% in Social studies. The lowest is 63% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on New Buffalo Middle School
New Buffalo Middle School sits in a small Lake Michigan resort town that wears two faces depending on the season. Summer brings boaters, beachgoers, and festival crowds to the compact downtown along Whittaker Street, where dining, lodging, and retail cluster near the harbor. Winters are quiet. The Four Winds Casino Resort is the largest single employer in the area, and tourism drives the commercial core. Schools and civic life are separated geographically, with the district's facilities on a campus off Clay Street away from the downtown harbor district. Publicly reported information notes that the Middle/High School building includes a performing arts center, computer labs, and indoor and outdoor running tracks, and in 2023 the district completed a dedicated STEAM building across Clay Street with professional-grade metallurgy and woodworking equipment.
That STEAM building reflects a district-wide curriculum emphasis. New Buffalo Area Schools teaches STEAM to all students from kindergarten through twelfth grade, focusing on problem-solving, creativity, critical thinking, and collaboration. The district was recognized as Michigan's Most Innovative District of the Year by MACUL in 2024 for these efforts. The district also has a pending ballot measure to renew its operating millage on business and non-homestead properties, which provides the majority of district revenue. Primary residences are not directly taxed by this millage, but failure to renew would carry real consequences for school funding.
The middle school itself is small, serving grades six through eight with a modest total enrollment spread fairly evenly across the three grades. The student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic population making up the next largest group. A smaller share of students qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch relative to many schools. Data on individualized education programs and English learner services was not available, so those profiles cannot be described here.
Academically, this is a strong-performing school by the most recent state assessments. In English language arts, sixth-grade proficiency is solidly above the statewide midpoint, and eighth-grade proficiency is exceptionally high, with nearly all tested students reaching proficiency. Seventh-grade ELA is lower but still above the state median. Math follows a similar pattern, with eighth grade the strongest performer and seventh grade the weakest. Eighth-grade science and social studies proficiency are both strong, social studies especially so. When measured across all tested subjects and grades, the school's overall proficiency places it in the top quartile relative to districts in Berrien County. No multi-year trend data was available, so it is not possible to say whether these results represent steady performance or recent change.
Because this is a middle school serving grades six through eight, there is no graduation rate to report. Chronic absenteeism data was also not available. Participation rates for the state assessments were missing across all tested grades, which a parent may want to look into further with the school.
The housing market in the 49117 zip code is expensive relative to both state and national benchmarks. Typical home values sit well above the Michigan median, and the price-to-income ratio is high. This reflects the town's status as a lakeside destination with substantial second-home and vacation property investment, and it means that families considering a move here should expect a housing market shaped more by resort demand than by local wages. Rental data was not available.
What this school offers is a small, personal middle-school environment in a district that has invested in innovation and hands-on learning, with academic results that stand out in the county. The tradeoff is a community where housing costs are driven by tourism and seasonal demand, and where the economic rhythm of the town shifts dramatically between summer and winter.
See more original research from School Decision →