The top reported proficiency rate is 78% in Math. The lowest is 58% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on New Buffalo Elementary School
New Buffalo Elementary School sits in a small Lake Michigan resort town about an hour's drive from downtown Chicago, a place where a tourism-driven commercial core meets quiet residential neighborhoods. The town's identity is seasonal. Summer brings boaters, beachgoers, and festival crowds to the harbor and downtown along Whittaker Street. Winters are slower. The Four Winds Casino Resort is the largest single employer in the area, and hospitality, retail, and marina operations drive much of the rest of the economy. A substantial retiree and second-home-owner population lives alongside year-round residents. The elementary school is part of a school campus off Clay Street, separate from the downtown harbor district, sharing the grounds with the middle/high school and a STEAM building completed in 2023.
The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade with a small enrollment, and its student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic population making up the next largest group. A moderate share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. Data on special education and English learner populations was not available. The school is a regular public school within New Buffalo Area Schools, not a charter or magnet.
State testing results from the most recent year are strong across the board. In math, third and fifth grade proficiency rates sit well above typical state levels, with fourth grade reported in a range that is essentially near the top. English language arts results follow the same pattern, with third and fifth grade proficiency solidly above average and fourth grade again near the ceiling. Fifth grade science proficiency is strong. Social studies is the one area where results are more modest, with a majority of fifth graders scoring proficient but a larger group falling short than in other subjects. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, though the overall academic picture is one of high performance. Participation rates were not reported for any tested grade or subject.
Placed relative to districts in Berrien County, the school's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades lands in the top quartile, above the highest-scoring district benchmark in the comparison set. This is a clear academic strength for families weighing options in the county. No graduation rate applies here, since the school does not serve high school grades. Chronic absenteeism data was not available.
The district has made STEAM education a centerpiece, teaching science, technology, engineering, arts, and mathematics across all grade levels K through twelve, with a dedicated building housing professional-grade metallurgy and woodworking equipment. New Buffalo Area Schools was publicly recognized as Michigan's Most Innovative District of the Year by MACUL in 2024 for this work. For an elementary family, this means early exposure to a curriculum built around problem-solving and creative thinking, with a clear pathway into the secondary programs on the same campus.
Housing in the area is expensive relative to both state and national benchmarks. The typical home value in the school's zip code sits well above the Michigan state benchmark and above the national benchmark, and values have been climbing at a brisk pace year over year. Estimated monthly mortgage costs at current rates are steep, and the price-to-income ratio is high. Rental data was not available. This housing market reflects the town's desirability as a lakeside and second-home destination, and it is a real factor for families considering a move into the district. The district's funding model is unusual in Michigan: as an out-of-formula district, it receives little state aid and relies on an operating millage on business and non-homestead properties. Primary residences are not directly taxed by this millage, but a pending renewal is on the ballot, and Headlee rollbacks have already reduced the effective rate. A family moving in should be aware that district funding stability depends on this local mechanism.
What this school offers is a small, high-performing elementary experience in a resort-town setting, with a district-wide STEAM focus and strong state assessment results. The trade-offs are a housing market stretched by vacation demand and a community whose rhythm shifts dramatically with the seasons.
See more original research from School Decision →