The top reported proficiency rate is 37% in Math. The lowest is 7% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Newaygo Elementary School
Newaygo Elementary School is the single elementary building in Newaygo Public School District, serving kindergarten through fourth grade in a small rural city on the Muskegon River. It occupies a renovated building that was formerly Velma Matson Elementary. After voters passed a bond in 2022 to upgrade district facilities, the district consolidated its two previous elementary schools into this one building and demolished the other, Vera Wilsie Elementary. That restructuring reduced the district from four buildings to three, and every elementary-aged child in the district now attends here. The building sits on Post Street, within the city's commercial core along State Road.
The school serves a sizable enrollment for its grade band, with class sizes across the five grades that are relatively even. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic minority and a small multiracial presence. The school reports no English learner or special education counts in the data we received, so those populations are unknown from the available information.
On state testing, Newaygo Elementary's results sit in the bottom quartile among districts in Newaygo County for overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades. In math, roughly a third to just under half of third and fourth graders reached proficiency on the most recent M-STEP, with fourth grade slightly behind third. In English language arts, results were lower, with under a third of students proficient in both tested grades. Science data exists only from an older testing cycle and is not comparable to current results, so it does not give a reliable current read. Participation rates were not reported. A parent considering this school may want to ask about how the district supports reading and math growth in the early grades, particularly given where the school stands relative to its county peers.
No graduation rate applies here because the school stops at fourth grade. Chronic absenteeism data was not reported. We looked for discipline, staffing, attendance, and course access information and found none, so those dimensions are left out rather than guessed. No magnet, charter, or Title I status was indicated in the available data.
The town of Newaygo is a small rural city in a county where tourism is the dominant economic sector, with agriculture and small manufacturing as secondary industries. The Muskegon River runs through the north side of town and functions as a primary recreation corridor, drawing visitors for steelhead fishing in spring and salmon in fall. Over half of Newaygo County lies within the Manistee National Forest, which supports hunting, camping, and RV tourism. Newaygo State Park sits atop embankments overlooking Hardy Dam Pond and offers rustic campgrounds, disc golf, and a stretch of the Dragon Trail. The Fred Meijer White Pine Trail State Park is a short drive east for hiking and biking. The city has a museum with local historical artifacts. No public transit system or public library was identified.
The built environment carries a late Victorian character, since a major fire in the town's history destroyed nearly all of its buildings and what was rebuilt reflects that period. State Road serves as the main street, where City Hall and commercial properties sit. The city has launched a facade grant program offering competitive matching grants for commercial and mixed-use property owners within its Tax Increment Finance Authority district, aimed at downtown building improvements. The population is growing slowly. No major new housing developments were identified.
Housing in the 49337 zip code is modestly priced relative to both the state and national benchmarks, and recent year-over-year appreciation has been running ahead of the state average. The estimated monthly mortgage on a typical home is manageable against national median household income, making the area relatively affordable for families buying at current mortgage rates. Rental data was not available.
What this means for a family. Newaygo Elementary is a consolidated, single-site elementary in a close-knit rural community with strong outdoor recreation access and affordable housing. Its state testing results are below the county median, and a parent weighing this school should ask the district directly about reading and math supports, what intervention services are in place, and how the post-consolidation building is being used to serve all students. The community context is quiet, river-oriented, and rooted, with slow growth and limited public amenities, which may suit families looking for a small-town setting and may be a drawback for those wanting more civic infrastructure.
See more original research from School Decision →