The top reported proficiency rate is 59% in Math. The lowest is 17% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on John Monteith Elementary School
John Monteith Elementary School sits in Grosse Pointe Woods, a primarily residential suburb about a dozen miles east of downtown Detroit and one of the five Grosse Pointe communities. The city took much of its current shape in the mid-20th century, built around and just after World War II, with single-family homes on tree-lined streets. It is the only one of the five Grosse Pointes with no Lake St. Clair shoreline of its own, fully landlocked, though the city owns Lake Front Park in neighboring St. Clair Shores. I-94 runs along the western edge, giving residents straightforward regional auto access. The city has no classic walkable downtown; civic life centers on the Robert E. Novitke Municipal Center. Population has been slowly declining over recent decades, with a slight uptick in the last census cycle, and the city adopted a 2024 Master Plan to guide its future.
Monteith is a regular public school serving kindergarten through fourth grade, part of the Grosse Pointe Public Schools system. Enrollment is moderate for an elementary building, with a fairly even distribution across the five grades. The student body is predominantly white, with Black students forming the next largest group, followed by smaller populations identifying as two or more races, Hispanic, and Asian. A modest share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, lower than what many Wayne County schools see, which lines up with the residential character of Grosse Pointe Woods. Data on English learners and students with individualized education programs was not available in the provided materials, so those gaps are named rather than filled.
On Michigan's M-STEP, the most recent results place Monteith in a strong position. Third-grade math proficiency is solidly above the state midpoint, and fourth-grade math is also above that mark. English language arts results are a touch more mixed: third-grade ELA sits roughly at the state midpoint, while fourth-grade ELA comes in somewhat above. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades lands in the top quartile relative to districts in Wayne County, which is a broad comparison set of well over a hundred districts. That is a genuine strength, especially in math, where both tested grades show clear command of the material.
Science and social studies results exist only from older testing cycles, reflecting grade-band shifts in what Michigan tests and when. Those older results are much lower, but they predate the current assessment framework and do not reflect present-day performance in a comparable way. A parent looking at the full picture should weigh the current math and ELA data more heavily and treat the legacy science and social studies figures as historical artifacts rather than current indicators. No participation rates were reported, and no multi-year trend data was available, so it is not possible to say whether proficiency is rising or falling from the provided data.
Because Monteith ends at fourth grade, there is no graduation rate, no advanced coursework, and no career or dual-credit pathway to speak of. Those are not gaps or failings; they simply do not apply to a building that serves the early grades. What a family is choosing here is a K through four entry point into the Grosse Pointe Public Schools system, with the expectation that students will move on to the district's upper-grade buildings for everything that comes next.
The housing market around Monteith is accessible by Grosse Pointe standards but still carries suburban pricing. Home values in the school's zip code are below both the state and national benchmarks, which is somewhat unusual for the Grosse Pointe communities and may reflect the landlocked, mid-century character of Grosse Pointe Woods relative to its waterfront neighbors. Rents are moderate, and the rental burden on local income is relatively manageable. Wayne County as a whole has seen a growing pool of active listings and new listings recently, with a modest dip in median listing price and homes sitting on the market a bit longer than a year ago, suggesting a market that has softened slightly in the parent district's favor.
No district-level program offerings, staffing data, attendance figures, or discipline data were available in the provided materials. The district brief did not surface any lasting parent-relevant changes within the recent window, though the closure of two other Grosse Pointe elementary schools was noted as an earlier event tied to declining enrollment. For Monteith specifically, there is no indication of imminent change in the data provided. A family considering this school is looking at a stable, academically strong early-grades building in a quiet, established suburb, feeding into a district system that carries students through the upper grades.
See more original research from School Decision →