The top reported proficiency rate is 23% in English language arts. The lowest is 12% in Social studies.
Original Research by School Decision on Cardinal Elementary
Cardinal Elementary sits on Marquette Avenue in Muskegon, part of Orchard View Schools. Though its listed grade span runs from kindergarten through ninth grade, the enrollment is concentrated in grades two through five, with only a handful of first graders and none currently in kindergarten or the upper grades. It functions as an elementary school in practice, serving roughly six hundred students from a working-class stretch of the city.
The student body reflects Muskegon's makeup. A slight majority of students are white, with Black students forming the next largest group, followed by smaller Hispanic and multiracial populations. The share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch is very high, which places this school among those serving communities with concentrated economic need. Data on English learners and special education enrollment was not available, so those populations cannot be characterized here. A parent may want to ask the school directly about support services in those areas.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessments for the current school year, proficiency rates sit below the midpoint for Muskegon County districts. In math, fewer than a quarter of third graders reached proficiency, and the share was lower in fourth and fifth grades. English language arts showed a somewhat different pattern: proficiency rose from third grade through fifth grade, ending with roughly a quarter of fifth graders proficient. Science results for fifth grade were in a similar low range, and social studies was the weakest spot, with only a small fraction of fifth graders proficient. Participation rates were not reported, and no multi-year trend data was available, so it is hard to say whether these results represent a decline, a plateau, or something else. The social studies assessment had a cut-score change flagged, which can affect comparability, but the overall picture is one where most students are not yet meeting state benchmarks. A parent considering this school would want to ask how staff approach reading and math intervention, and what the response to these results looks like in daily classroom practice.
Because Cardinal serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and the chronic absenteeism figure was not available. Civil rights and discipline data was also absent from the available sources, so questions about suspension patterns or access to advanced coursework would need to go directly to the district.
Orchard View Schools, the parent district, approved a new strategic plan in March of last year, developed through community input. It centers on five areas: student achievement, social-emotional learning, staff recruitment and retention, facilities, and community engagement. That plan is the framework the district has said will guide its decisions on classroom instruction, support services, and building improvements in the coming years. How quickly its priorities translate into visible changes at Cardinal is something a parent could reasonably track.
Muskegon itself is the county seat and the largest city on Lake Michigan's eastern shore. It carries a manufacturing identity from its lumber-era origins through later production of paper, automotive and turbine parts, tools, machinery, and chemicals. Downtown runs along the southern shore of Muskegon Lake and holds the county's main civic and cultural venues: a convention center, an arena bearing Trinity Health's name, the Frauenthal Center for the Performing Arts, the Muskegon Museum of Art, and a historic district of restored lumber-baron mansions. The Lake Express ferry connects the city to Milwaukee across the lake. Public transit runs through the Muskegon Area Transit System. The EPA's completion of a long-running Muskegon Lake cleanup, publicly reported in 2022, was expected to bring new economic activity to downtown and nearby lakefront neighborhoods, though specific housing developments were not detailed in available sources.
Housing in the school's zip code is affordable by both state and national standards. Typical home values and rents sit well below Michigan's statewide benchmark and farther below the national one. Rent absorbs a modest share of household income relative to the mortgage cost difference, which may appeal to families looking for lower-cost entry points, though it also reflects the economic conditions that shape the school's enrollment.
What Cardinal offers is a neighborhood elementary serving a diverse, high-need student population in an affordable lakeside city, with academic results that currently lag county norms. The district has named student achievement and social-emotional learning as top priorities. Whether those commitments produce movement in proficiency will be the question for families watching this school.
See more original research from School Decision →