The top reported proficiency rate is 38% in Science. The lowest is 23% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Starr Elementary School
Starr Elementary School sits in Plainwell, a small Allegan County city that calls itself "The Island City" because the Kalamazoo River and a historic millrace wrap around its downtown core. The school serves pre-kindergarten through fifth grade as one of three elementary buildings in the Plainwell Community Schools district, operating as a regular public school on its own campus on School Drive, separate from the compact downtown. Plainwell functions as a bedroom community between Kalamazoo to the south and Grand Rapids to the north, connected by a US freeway that makes regional commuting straightforward. The local employment base blends industrial manufacturing, food processing at the JBS plant, healthcare, and public education, giving the area a working-class, mixed-economy character rather than a purely suburban one.
The school's enrollment is moderate for an elementary building, with a fairly even distribution across the grade levels. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which speaks to the economic mix of the community. The student body is predominantly white, with a smaller Hispanic presence and very small representation from other racial and ethnic groups. Information on English learners and students with individualized education programs was not available in the data provided, so those populations could not be characterized here.
On Michigan's M-STEP assessments, Starr's results show a mixed picture across subjects and grade levels. In English language arts, proficiency climbs as students move up the grades, with third grade posting the lowest rate and fifth grade reaching the strongest mark. Fourth grade lands in between. The pattern suggests some growth in literacy skills as children progress through the building, which is a constructive sign even though the younger grades start from a lower baseline. Math results follow a similar upward arc, with third grade again the weakest and fourth grade the strongest, though fifth grade dips back down somewhat. Science proficiency in fifth grade sits at a middling level, and social studies is the lowest of the reported subjects for fifth graders.
When placed against other districts in Allegan County, Starr's overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades falls in the bottom quartile. That comparison reflects the combined picture of the school's current state assessment results. A parent weighing this school may want to look into what targeted academic supports and interventions are in place, particularly in the early grades where proficiency is lowest, and to ask how the building is working to close those gaps as students advance.
Because Starr serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate to report, and the school does not have high school-level course access data. Chronic absenteeism data was also not available in the provided materials. Program offerings specific to Starr were not included in the data, so families would need to inquire directly about enrichment, intervention, or special programming available at the building level.
Housing in the 49080 zip code sits below the national benchmark and modestly above the Michigan state average, with home values showing steady year-over-year appreciation. The price-to-income ratio suggests that buying a home in the area is somewhat more demanding than the national norm relative to local wages, though estimated monthly mortgage costs are higher than typical rent by a meaningful margin. Rent data was not available, so a full rental picture could not be assembled. The broader economic environment features a national unemployment rate that has held steady, and median household income that has been gradually rising in real terms over the past several years.
Plainwell itself has seen a slow population decline since the 2020 census, and the city's small geographic footprint limits large-scale expansion. Planning efforts appear focused on redevelopment rather than rapid growth, with a downtown development authority and tax increment finance structures in place. For a family considering Starr Elementary, the setting offers a small-town feel with river-based recreation, a walkable downtown core, and reasonable access to two larger metro areas, paired with an elementary school whose academic results are currently below the county midpoint but show internal growth from grade to grade.
See more original research from School Decision →