The top reported proficiency rate is 0% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Comfrey Elementary
Comfrey Elementary serves students from prekindergarten through sixth grade in a single building that sits within the tiny agricultural town of Comfrey in southern Minnesota. The school is the elementary arm of the Comfrey Public School District, which covers the town and the surrounding farmland. With a small enrollment, Comfrey Elementary is a place where most families in the community know one another, and the school building itself functions as a central civic landmark. The town of Comfrey is compact, under half a square mile, with a population that has been essentially flat in recent years. The housing stock is almost entirely owner-occupied single-family homes, and the area is rural, with the nearest significant commercial services likely a drive away. The local economy revolves around agriculture; the school district is one of the larger employers in town.
The student body is overwhelmingly white, with a very small Hispanic population. A substantial share of students come from low-income households, as measured by eligibility for free or reduced-price lunch. The school does not report the share of students receiving special education services or English learner support, so those details are not available from the data provided. The school is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and there is no Title I status listed.
State assessment results for Comfrey Elementary present an unusual picture. For the most recent testing year, individual grade-level data for math and reading in grades three through six shows that no student met the proficiency standard on the Minnesota Comprehensive Assessments. However, the school's aggregated proficiency rate across all tested grades in that same year tells a different story, with a higher share of students reaching proficiency. This discrepancy between the grade-level and school-level figures is not explained in the available data. Parents should be aware of this inconsistency and may want to follow up directly with the school or district for a clear explanation of how the results are reported and what they mean for student performance. Compared with other districts in Brown County, Comfrey Elementary’s overall proficiency index places it at the lower end. Science testing data for fifth grade was suppressed due to a small number of test-takers, so no conclusion can be drawn there.
Because the school serves only through sixth grade, there is no graduation rate to consider. The elementary program is the only public school option within the town for this age range; students move on to a combined middle and high school in the same district after sixth grade, likely in the same building or adjacent. The school building was rebuilt after a devastating tornado decades ago, which speaks to the community’s investment in its school.
Housing in the Comfrey area is notably affordable relative to much of Minnesota. Home values in the zip code are below the state median, and mortgage rates are in line with national averages. For a family seeking a lower-cost, rural setting with a very small school, Comfrey Elementary offers that environment. The town itself has limited amenities: two city parks, a few campsites, and a nearby historic site with ancient petroglyphs, but no public library or transit. Daily life requires a vehicle for most errands beyond the immediate neighborhood.
The school’s small size means class sizes are likely very small, and teachers can give a lot of individual attention. The peer group is homogeneous, which may be a consideration for families seeking more diversity. Academic outcomes based on the state’s testing data are ambiguous, and the conflicting numbers warrant a closer look from any parent evaluating the school. For families who prioritize a close-knit rural community, low housing costs, and a school where everyone knows each other, Comfrey Elementary fits that mold, but its academic track record is not clearly strong when measured against nearby districts.
See more original research from School Decision →