The top reported proficiency rate is 40% in Math. The lowest is 15% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Karlstad Elementary
Karlstad Elementary serves prekindergarten through sixth grade as a regular public school within the Tri-County School District, a system that also includes a secondary school farther along the grade span. The elementary school is located in Karlstad, a small rural city in northwestern Minnesota’s Kittson County that calls itself the Moose Capital of the North. The town’s economy is heavily agricultural, anchored by two larger employers: Wikstrom Telephone Company, which serves much of the region, and Mattracks, a manufacturer of track-conversion systems. Karlstad’s population has declined over recent decades, and its built environment is compact, with a Main Street, low-density residential blocks, and civic amenities such as parks, a nine-hole golf course, camping facilities, and nearby wildlife management areas. A parent considering the school should note that the setting is genuinely rural, with minimal street life and a small-town pace.
The school enrolls roughly ninety students, a size that gives the building a small-scale feel. The student body is predominantly White, with very small numbers of Asian, Black, American Indian, and Hispanic students. About half of the students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a figure that roughly matches the national share for high-poverty schools. Because Karlstad Elementary serves only grades PK-6, it does not report a graduation rate; that metric applies to the secondary school in the district, which is not covered here.
Minnesota administered state assessments in math, reading, and science for the 2024-25 school year, and the results show an uneven picture. In third-grade math, roughly three in ten students met the proficiency standard. Fourth-grade math, by contrast, showed a very high proficiency rate, with about nine in ten students hitting the mark. Fifth-grade math dropped back to under four in ten, and sixth-grade math recorded no students scoring proficient. The pattern in English language arts is similarly mixed: third-grade reading showed about a quarter of students proficient, fourth grade just under half, fifth grade just under half, and sixth grade again recorded no proficient scores. Fifth-grade science, the only tested science grade, had roughly one in six students proficient. The state changed the science assessment and cut scores for this year, so that single-year figure should be interpreted cautiously. The overall proficiency index, which averages all tested subjects and grades, placed Karlstad Elementary in the bottom quartile relative to the three districts in Kittson County. Given the small number of tested students in each grade, a single cohort’s performance can swing considerably, and a parent may want to ask the school how it supports students who are struggling, especially in the upper elementary grades where proficiency rates drop sharply.
The school’s student-support data has gaps. Information on students with disabilities and English learners was not available, nor were discipline or absenteeism figures. These are common gaps in this school’s profile, and a family with a child who receives special education services or who is learning English should inquire directly about caseload sizes and accommodation structures. Staffing data, including teacher-to-student ratios, was also absent. The absence of this information does not imply a problem, but it means decision-making parents will need to fill in details through a school visit or conversation with the principal.
The housing market in Karlstad is affordable relative to the state and nation. Home values in the area are well below Minnesota’s median, and the price-to-income ratio suggests that a typical household can afford a home without being stretched. Rents are below major metro benchmarks. The local unemployment rate is consistent with the national figure, and median household income, while lower than the Minnesota norm, supports the area’s lower cost of living.
Karlstad Elementary is the kind of school that suits a family seeking a small, rural elementary experience where the school is woven into the town’s daily life. The academic results are uneven, with strong fourth-grade math standing out against weak sixth-grade performance, and a parent would want to understand how the school differentiates instruction across this age range. The absence of several data points means that some of the usual checkboxes for school quality will need to be filled by direct inquiry. For a family already oriented to rural northwestern Minnesota, this school offers a close-knit setting at a modest cost of living.
See more original research from School Decision →