The top reported proficiency rate is 15% in Science. The lowest is 12% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carnahan Middle
Carnahan Middle serves sixth and seventh grade students in the St. Louis City school district, a regular public school located on South Broadway in the city. The school is small, and its enrollment skews heavily toward sixth grade; seventh grade enrollment was reported as zero in the most recent data, meaning the school essentially operates as a single-grade building for that year. More than nine out of ten students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a reflection of the economic circumstances of the community it serves. Almost nine out of ten students are Black, with small shares of white and Hispanic students.
State testing results from the Missouri Assessment Program show a school where academic proficiency rates are well below the midpoint for districts in St. Louis city. In math, sixth grade proficiency was roughly one in five students. Seventh grade math, with no students enrolled, had no results to report. Eighth grade math proficiency was about one in eight. In English language arts, roughly one in ten sixth graders scored proficient, along with about one in seven seventh graders and about one in six eighth graders. Science results for eighth graders showed proficiency around one in seven. The overall proficiency index across all tested subjects and grades places Carnahan Middle in the bottom quartile among St. Louis city districts. A parent looking at these scores would find consistent, low attainment across subjects and grade levels, and may want to ask the school what academic supports and interventions are in place for students who are not yet meeting state standards.
The school is part of the St. Louis City school district, a large urban district. The district brief turned up no recent parent-relevant changes, so the district context is stable in the sense of no reported new initiatives or structural shifts.
St. Louis itself is an independent city with a mix of residential neighborhoods and commercial districts, a diverse economy anchored by service industries, manufacturing, trade, transportation, and aviation. Major employers include the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, the National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency, Barnes-Jewish Hospital, and several research universities. Key civic and cultural anchors such as Forest Park, the Saint Louis Zoo, and the Gateway Arch are part of the city's fabric. The city limits its political boundaries as an independent city, a historical decision that shapes its current context.
Housing in the area shows a mix of ownership and rental. The typical home value is moderately below the national benchmark and below the state benchmark as well, making this a relatively more affordable pocket of the metro area. Rents have been rising modestly. The median household income nationally is below what many families would need to comfortably carry a mortgage at current interest rates, and the local context of high poverty among the student population is consistent with the economic data: a substantial share of families are likely cost-burdened by housing.
For a parent considering Carnahan Middle, the core academic picture is the central feature. The school serves a high-poverty population, which in many large urban districts correlates with lower test scores, and the data here bears that out. A family would want to understand what the school offers beyond the core academic program, whether that is enrichment, extracurriculars, or support services, and how the school approaches instruction for students who arrive behind grade level. The small size means a close-knit environment, though this year's enrollment pattern of only sixth graders is unusual and worth clarifying with the district for future years. The broader city provides ample cultural and institutional resources, though access to them from the school and neighborhood is a practical question a family would need to explore on the ground.
See more original research from School Decision →