The top reported proficiency rate is 27% in Math. The lowest is 26% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Mcevans School
McEvans School sits along Highway 61 North in Shaw, a small Mississippi Delta town in Bolivar County. It serves kindergarten through sixth grade as part of the West Bolivar Consolidated School District, the same system that covers most of Shaw. The town itself is tiny and predominantly residential, with limited commercial activity typical of small Delta communities. Publicly reported sources describe a population that has been declining steadily over recent decades, with no major housing developments or growth projects on the horizon. Shaw carries a piece of cultural history through its Mississippi Blues Trail marker honoring native son David "Honeyboy" Edwards, and city hall serves as the municipal anchor with regular board meetings. But by most accounts, this is a quiet, contracting community.
The school's enrollment is small, with students spread fairly evenly across the seven grade levels it serves. The student body is almost entirely Black or African American, with a very small number of Hispanic, white, and multiracial students. Every student at McEvans qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, which places the school squarely in a high-poverty context. The data did not include counts for students with individualized education programs or English learners, so those population slices remain unnamed here.
On state assessments, the most recent results tell a story of early-grade strength that does not carry into the upper elementary years. In math, third and fourth graders showed moderate proficiency, with roughly half of fourth graders reaching the proficient threshold. By fifth grade, however, math proficiency dropped to zero, and sixth grade remained very low. English language arts followed a similar arc. Third graders showed modest proficiency, fourth graders reached the halfway mark, and then fifth and sixth grades fell sharply. Science, tested only in fifth grade, landed well below the midpoint. Participation rates were not reported for any grade or subject.
The pattern here is clear and worth a parent's attention. The early grades at McEvans appear to be building foundational skills with some success, but something happens between fourth and fifth grade where proficiency collapses across both math and reading. A parent considering this school would want to ask what instructional or curricular shifts occur in that transition, and what supports are available for students as they move into the upper grades. The school may have plans or interventions in place that the data does not capture, so contacting the administration directly would be a reasonable next step.
Housing in the Shaw zip code is inexpensive by any standard, with typical home values well below the state average and far below national figures. Values have been declining recently. For a family already rooted in the Delta, the cost of living is low. For a family weighing a move here, the declining housing market mirrors the broader population contraction and may reflect limited economic opportunity in the immediate area. No rental data was available, so the rental picture is incomplete. The national unemployment rate has held steady in a moderate range, but local economic conditions in Shaw itself were not detailed beyond the observation that commercial activity is limited.
The district context adds one piece of structural history. In 2020, West Bolivar Consolidated reorganized its secondary schools, consolidating the former high school and middle school into a single campus in Rosedale for grades seven through twelve. That change affects where McEvans students will go after sixth grade. The two schools in Shaw, McEvans and the high school, had merged in 2020 but became separate institutions again as of 2024.
What is missing from the available data is worth naming. There was no information on staffing ratios, teacher qualifications, discipline practices, course offerings beyond standard state-tested subjects, attendance patterns, or any specialized programs the school might offer. No multi-year trend data was available, so it is not possible to say whether these proficiency numbers represent an improvement or a decline from prior years. The absence of a neighbor comparison set means this school's results are presented only against the state assessment framework, not positioned against nearby schools.
McEvans is a small, high-poverty elementary school in a quiet Delta town, showing some real traction in the early grades and serious academic challenges as students approach middle school. Families with children in kindergarten through fourth grade may find a workable starting point here. Families with older elementary students should look closely at the fifth and sixth grade results and ask the school directly what is being done to reverse that decline.
See more original research from School Decision →