The top reported proficiency rate is 33% in Math. The lowest is 23% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Pine Butte Elementary Sch
Pine Butte Elementary School serves students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Colstrip, a small southeastern Montana town historically built around coal mining and power generation. The school is part of the Colstrip Elementary District, and its enrollment skews young and diverse: a substantial share of students identify as American Indian or Alaska Native, and a similar share identify as White, with smaller numbers of Hispanic students and students of two or more races. About half of the student body qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a middle ground on economic measures. A parent or resident considering this school should note that state testing data for special populations, such as students with disabilities or English learners, was not available in the reported data.
On academic performance, the school's results are a mixed picture. On the 2023-24 Smarter Balanced assessments, proficiency in math and English language arts fell below what many families would consider a strong benchmark, though the school's overall proficiency index across tested subjects ranked above the midpoint among districts in Rosebud County. Science proficiency, measured by the Montana Science Assessment, was lower. These figures suggest that while Pine Butte is not the highest-performing elementary school in the region, it is not the lowest either. A parent may want to ask the school about specific instructional supports, particularly in reading and math, to get a clearer sense of how the school addresses these outcomes. Because the school serves only early grades, no graduation rate or chronic absenteeism data is reported—those metrics simply do not apply here.
The school sits within Colstrip, a community shaped by its industrial anchors: the Rosebud Mine and the Colstrip Steam Electric Station. The town has a residential feel with many parks and green spaces, including a lake and a walking trail. Street life is minimal; the town is spread out and oriented toward outdoor recreation rather than a pedestrian downtown. Housing in the Colstrip area is notably more affordable than statewide or national benchmarks, with home values having seen a modest decline in the most recent year. For a family looking for lower-cost housing in a rural, resource-economy town, this could be a practical option. The local economy is dominated by the mine and power plant, but both face long-term uncertainty: two of the plant's four units have already closed, and the remaining units face pressure. The mine received an expansion approval, extending its life, but the community's population has been declining from a past boom period. A parent should consider what that economic trajectory might mean for school funding and community stability down the road.
The district brief found no recent major changes reported for the Colstrip Elementary District, though the power plant's earlier unit shutdowns could have property-tax implications that aren't detailed. Pine Butte Elementary itself appears to be a stable, open school serving a modest enrollment for its grade band. Its strongest academic comparison is within Rosebud County, where it sits above the midpoint. For a parent weighing this school, the key considerations are the moderate proficiency levels, the substantial Native American and White student mix, the affordable housing market, and the broader community context of a coal town navigating an uncertain energy transition. This school fits a family seeking a small-town, rural elementary experience with a diverse student body and a community tied to natural resources, where the cost of living is lower than much of the state.
See more original research from School Decision →