The top reported proficiency rate is 50% in Math. The lowest is 38% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Montclair Elementary
Montclair Elementary serves early grades from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade in Fayetteville, a mid-sized city in Cumberland County shaped by its proximity to Fort Liberty and a steady flow of military-connected families. The school is a regular public elementary housed in the Cumberland County Schools system, which is currently navigating a major facilities consolidation in response to substantial deferred maintenance and budget pressure.
The student body at Montclair is economically disadvantaged; nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The enrollment spans roughly a mid-range size for an elementary school serving this age group, with the largest cohorts in kindergarten and the early primary grades. The student population is racially diverse, with Black students representing the largest single group, followed by Hispanic students, with smaller shares of white, Asian, and multiracial peers. The specific counts of students receiving special education services or learning English as a second language are not publicly available, so families may want to reach out to the school directly to understand the full scope of support services available.
State testing data from the most recent school year shows academic performance below the midpoint. In math, about half of tested third through fifth graders demonstrated proficiency. In English language arts, roughly comparable results hold, with about half meeting proficiency standards. Science results were notably weaker, with proficiency near 40 percent. These figures represent the students tested in those grades; kindergarten through second grade are not state-tested, which is standard practice statewide. Trend data is not yet available because the state changed its science assessment, so historical comparisons cannot be drawn. A parent may want to discuss with the school what targeted support and curriculum work are underway to strengthen performance across these areas.
The school sits in a residential area of Fayetteville accessible by car along major arterials typical of the region. The city itself is overwhelmingly car-dependent; public transit exists via the Fayetteville Area System of Transit but is limited in frequency and coverage. The surrounding housing market reflects modest growth and military-driven demand, with home values and rents moderately below state and national benchmarks, making the area relatively affordable compared to many Sun Belt neighborhoods. This affordability has drawn families relocating from higher-cost regions.
Cumberland County Schools is in the midst of significant structural change. A major facilities study released in 2025 identified substantial repair and modernization needs across the district's buildings. In response, the school board voted to close Manchester Elementary and J.W. Coon effective in the coming year, with additional closures under consideration through a formal process. The district is also operating under a structural budget deficit following the end of federal pandemic relief funding, which has prompted staff reductions and consolidation as the core strategy to address shortfalls. These shifts will reshape attendance zones, busing routes, and school communities across the county over the next several years. Families should monitor district announcements as consolidation proceeds, since Montclair's attendance zone and the services available could be affected.
For families selecting an elementary school in this area, Montclair offers a neighborhood school setting serving the full early-grade span in a diverse, economically challenged community. The academic results indicate a need for focused instructional improvement, particularly in math and science. The broader district context of budget constraints and facility consolidation means that school programming, staffing levels, and attendance boundaries remain in flux. A visit to the school and a conversation with the principal about current priorities, support for learners below grade level, and how the school is approaching the state assessment results would help families understand what kind of academic pathway and resource environment to expect.
See more original research from School Decision →