The top reported proficiency rate is 68% in Science. The lowest is 60% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Audrey W. Garrett Elementary
Audrey W. Garrett Elementary is a pre-K through fifth-grade school in Mebane, a fast-growing industrial and residential hub at the I-40/I-85 junction in Alamance County. The school serves a population that is economically diverse and racially mixed, with a substantial share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch and roughly equal representation across White, Black, and Hispanic students, alongside smaller shares of Asian and multiracial students.
The school's state assessment results show math proficiency above English language arts. On recent End-of-Grade tests, math proficiency sits at a point closer to two-thirds of students meeting or exceeding standards, while reading and language arts trails at roughly three-fifths. Science proficiency, tested only at upper elementary grades, is higher. These results place the school's overall performance in the lower-to-middle range relative to its peers. Parents evaluating the school should understand that while a majority of students demonstrate grade-level proficiency in math, a meaningful share do not, and the same is true in English language arts. This is not an atypical profile for a high-poverty elementary school in a rural-to-suburban county, but a parent focused on strong academic outcomes may want to learn more about the school's approach to reading and literacy intervention.
The enrollment is substantial for an elementary school in this region and spans evenly across grades, with prekindergarten being quite small. The student body reflects Mebane's rapid residential growth and economic diversity. Housing in the school's zip code is modestly priced relative to state and national benchmarks, and monthly rents remain affordable on local incomes, though the rental market has tightened slightly in the past year. This economic profile and the school's Title I eligibility suggest that many families are working- to middle-class, some facing housing instability or economic pressure.
Mebane itself is transforming quickly. The city is publicly reported as one of the fastest-growing in the Piedmont, with large new residential subdivisions approved or under construction on its edges and major manufacturing and distribution employers along the interstate corridor. The historic downtown along Clay and Fifth Streets has become a focus for civic investment and walkability, with restaurants, breweries, a farmers market, and a social district drawing foot traffic. The Mebane Public Library sits downtown on First Street, and parks, recreation facilities, and the Mebane Arts and Community Center provide community anchors. This growth has brought public attention to school overcapacity; parents should be aware that Alamance-Burlington Schools is managing enrollment pressures across the district. On the high school side, Southeast Alamance High School opened in fall 2023 as the district's first new high school in over fifty years, redrawing attendance zones and reducing crowding at the older high schools, though capacity pressures at elementary and middle schools persist.
The broader school district has completed a substantial bond-funded renovation and safety upgrade program across its buildings. All district schools now have key-card entry and security vestibules, a visible structural change reflecting national priorities on school security. Additionally, beginning in the 2025-2026 school year, all Alamance-Burlington Schools implemented classroom cell phone restrictions, requiring students to power off phones and store them during class time. These are shifts in school culture and classroom management that parents will notice immediately.
Audrey W. Garrett serves a school-age population in a community experiencing genuine, rapid change. The school's academic outcomes reflect a student body with significant economic and language diversity and point to real work ahead in reading proficiency, while math proficiency suggests stronger footing. For families drawn to Mebane's growth, affordability, and employment base, this school represents an accessible elementary option serving a genuinely mixed community. For families prioritizing top-tier academic results, a closer look at the school's literacy supports and classroom practices would be warranted.
See more original research from School Decision →