The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Science. The lowest is 74% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Smith Middle
Smith Middle is a regular public middle school in Chapel Hill, North Carolina, serving approximately 750 students in grades 6 through 8. The school draws from Chapel Hill and Carrboro, two adjacent towns centered on the University of North Carolina campus and its associated medical systems. The surrounding area is characterized by high median household income, a strong education-anchored economy, and active civic infrastructure including extensive parks, greenways, and a fare-free transit system. The area is currently experiencing significant housing development after a decade of little growth, with major mixed-use projects and affordable housing initiatives underway.
Smith Middle's state assessment results from 2024-25 show proficiency rates above three-quarters of students in English language arts and mathematics, with science proficiency notably stronger. The school's overall proficiency sits well above the median among districts in Orange County. Students tested represent typical variation across race and ethnicity, with roughly one in four receiving free or reduced-price lunch benefits. These proficiency rates suggest solidly above-average academic performance for the middle grades in a state-tested context.
The school's student body is diverse and reflects the Chapel Hill community. About four in ten students are White, roughly one in five are Asian, and Black and Hispanic students each represent a meaningful share. Multiracial enrollment is also present. About one-quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a mix of family economic circumstances rather than concentrated poverty.
As a middle school, Smith offers the core academic program in math, English language arts, and science. Starting in the 2025-26 school year, the Chapel Hill-Carrboro City Schools district implemented an "away for the day" cell phone policy at the middle school level, meaning students store phones in lockers during the instructional day. The district is also rolling out a new science and engineering standards curriculum that aligns with hands-on, inquiry-based approaches. In 2026-27, a new English language arts curriculum based on the science of reading will arrive at the district level, shifting instructional focus to phonics, phonemic awareness, comprehension, fluency, and vocabulary.
The district faces real enrollment and budget pressures. In June 2026, the board voted unanimously to close Glenwood Elementary at the end of 2026-27, triggering district-wide redistricting of elementary attendance zones. The district has shed roughly one thousand students since the pandemic. However, the town itself is in the midst of a housing boom, with major residential projects approved or under construction that could reshape school enrollments in coming years. In November 2024, Orange County voters approved a major facilities bond that will fund rebuilding of three of the district's oldest elementary schools.
For a family choosing Smith Middle, the school offers solid core academics in a diverse, educated peer group within a university-anchored town known for civic investment and strong community infrastructure. The state test results suggest the academic experience produces measurable proficiency above regional averages, though like any middle school, individual student outcomes depend on fit, course selection, and the transition experience itself. Parents may want to explore with the school how it supports middle grades transition and social-emotional growth alongside academics, particularly given the recent policy shifts around technology and curriculum.
See more original research from School Decision →