The top reported proficiency rate is 64% in Math. The lowest is 56% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Cartoogechaye Elementary
Cartoogechaye Elementary is a small public school serving pre-kindergarten through fourth grade in Franklin, a mountain town in southwestern North Carolina. The school sits in a rural county-seat community shaped by outdoor recreation, tourism, and a long association with gem mining. The student body is predominantly white, with a substantial Hispanic population; nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic profile of the surrounding area.
The school has reported math proficiency at a rate above half among third and fourth graders tested, with English language arts proficiency somewhat lower. State testing data was available only for grades three through eight combined; no trend data across years was available to show whether proficiency is rising, holding steady, or shifting. A parent may want to look into how these proficiency numbers break down by individual grade and ask the school about supports for students not yet meeting grade-level standards in reading and writing, since the ELA result sits notably lower than math.
The enrollment is small and stable across the grade band, with fairly even class sizes from kindergarten through fourth grade. The school draws almost entirely from families qualifying for lunch assistance, a high concentration that shapes the economic pressures on both the families and the school's resources. State data on special-education enrollment and English-learner identification was not available in the reported records.
Franklin itself has grown modestly over recent decades and continues to attract residents drawn to its mountain location, outdoor access, and lower cost of living. Housing costs are moderate relative to state and national benchmarks. The town's economy centers on government, healthcare, tourism and outdoor recreation, and education; a major new hospital facility opened in 2022, and downtown remains a compact walkable core with restaurants, shops, and cultural attractions. The Macon County Public Library and Southwestern Community College are nearby civic anchors.
The broader district context matters for families considering this area. Macon County Schools is undertaking its most significant capital project in district history: a brand-new Franklin High School, designed as a single ADA-compliant building with substantial Career and Technical Education space, broke ground in late 2024. The school will replace a 1950s-era campus. A state capital grant is covering part of the cost, but the county is also relying on property tax funding. Voters in the county have twice rejected a proposed local sales tax increase for school funding, in 2022 and again in 2024, so the district continues to depend primarily on property taxes. For families weighing a move to the area, this means the property tax picture will remain central to school funding decisions. The new high school represents a long-term investment in the district's physical infrastructure and its ability to offer modern Career and Technical programs to students exiting elementary and middle school.
See more original research from School Decision →