The top reported proficiency rate is 44% in Math. The lowest is 8% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Creswell Elementary
Creswell Elementary served kindergarten through fifth grade in a small town in the Inner Banks until January 2025. The school has now been consolidated with Pines Elementary into Washington County Elementary School, a new PK-12 campus in Plymouth about a short drive away. This consolidation is a substantial change for Creswell-area families: there is no longer a neighborhood elementary school in town, and students now bus to the county seat.
For families considering the area, the academic picture is mixed and warrants attention. The most recent state testing data, from spring 2024, showed a school serving roughly a small group of third through fifth graders. In math, the proficiency rate was in the low-to-mid range. English language arts proficiency was notably lower, in the bottom quartile of typical performance. Science testing included only a handful of students and showed very limited proficiency. These are not strong results, and a parent may want to understand from the school and district what academic supports are in place and what improvements are planned under the new consolidated structure.
The student body was economically disadvantaged: a very substantial share of students qualified for free or reduced-price lunch. Racially, the enrollment was majority Black, with meaningful populations of White and Hispanic students and very small numbers of other groups. Data on special education and English learner enrollment were not available.
The town itself is a very small place on the western edge of the Scuppernong River, with a walkable historic downtown and short distances within the town grid. Most residents rent rather than own. Pettigrew State Park, about a short drive away on Lake Phelps, anchors outdoor recreation. The town's population has been essentially flat or declining over the past decade. Housing values are modest, and the home market is thin, with only a handful of homes listed at any given time. Most workers commute out of town; in-town employment is very small. Growth across rural eastern North Carolina, including Washington County, has lagged the statewide boom in urban and suburban areas.
The closure of Creswell Elementary and consolidation into a new PK-12 building in Plymouth represents the district's response to declining enrollment and operational efficiency. For a family in Creswell, this means losing the neighborhood school and committing to a longer daily ride, but it also means access to a brand-new facility and a unified PreK-12 environment. The trade-off between convenience and facility quality, and between a traditional small-school model and a consolidated one, is something a parent should weigh directly with the district.
See more original research from School Decision →