Original Research by School Decision on Mckinley Elementary School
McKinley Elementary is a regular public school in the Fargo 1 district, serving kindergarten through fifth grade on the city's north side. It is a small school for its grade band, with roughly two dozen students per grade level. The student body is majority white, with smaller groups of Hispanic, Black, Asian, Native American, multiracial, and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students. About half the enrollment qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, a substantial share that places the school in a more working-class position than some of Fargo's other elementary buildings. Data on English learners and special-education enrollment was not available, so those populations cannot be characterized here.
Fargo itself is a mid-sized regional center whose economy has moved well beyond its agricultural roots. Healthcare, higher education, technology, and retail now anchor the city, with Sanford Health and Microsoft both operating regional campuses downtown and North Dakota State University woven into the city's identity. The metro area has had among the lowest unemployment rates in the country for years, which gives the local housing market a steady floor. Postwar interstate construction pushed growth south and west of the original downtown core, and much of the city's newer residential development follows that pattern. The north side, where McKinley sits, has a different feel from the sprawling south Fargo subdivisions; it is closer to downtown and the older street grid, though car dependence remains the norm outside the immediate core.
State assessment results from the current year are available under North Dakota's A-PLUS assessment, but the state reports proficiency in ranges rather than exact figures, and the assessment itself underwent a name and cut-score change this year. That means no trend comparison to prior years is possible, and a parent looking at results should treat them as a baseline under a new test rather than a continuation of an old one.
The results paint a mixed picture that varies by grade and subject. In math, third-grade proficiency falls in a low range, fourth grade sits modestly higher but still below midpoint, and fifth grade rises to a moderate level. ELA follows a similar pattern: third grade lands in a middle range, fourth grade dips lower, and fifth grade recovers to a moderate level. Science, tested only in fourth grade at this school, shows proficiency in a low range. Aggregated across all tested grades, roughly two-fifths of students reached proficiency in math, about a third did so in ELA, and roughly a fifth in science. Participation was solid across all grades and subjects tested. These results suggest that McKinley's older elementary students are performing more strongly than its younger ones, and that reading outcomes are somewhat stronger than science. The lower science and early-grade math results are worth a closer conversation with the school, particularly whether the new assessment's cut scores are part of what is driving the appearance of low results, or whether instruction in those areas and grades is an area the school is actively working on.
The school sits in a zip code where home values run below the state benchmark and well below the national one, making it one of the more affordable parts of the Fargo area for ownership. Rents are also modest relative to income, and the gap between monthly rent and a monthly mortgage payment is wide enough that renting costs substantially less than owning at current interest rates. For families weighing a move into the attendance area, this means the housing market is comparatively accessible, though current mortgage rates make ownership a stretch for many households even with lower price points.
Several pieces of information that would help round out a parent's picture are missing. The data did not include Title I status, staffing levels, discipline data, attendance rates, course or program offerings, or any comparison to neighboring schools within the district. The district brief did not surface any parent-relevant changes such as referendums, curriculum shifts, or facility plans, so there is little to report on the district's current direction beyond what the assessment data already reflects. IEP and English-learner counts were also unavailable.
What the available evidence does show is a small, economically diverse north-side elementary school in a growing regional city, with assessment results that are uneven across grades and subjects but trend stronger in the upper elementary years. Families drawn to a smaller school environment in an established, affordable part of Fargo may find McKinley worth a visit, particularly to ask how the school supports its early-grade math learners and what it is doing with science instruction.
See more original research from School Decision →