The top reported proficiency rate is 72% in English language arts. The lowest is 37% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on West Freehold School
West Freehold School serves students from preschool through fifth grade in the Freehold Township School District. It is a regular public school, and it sits within a community context that many families will recognize: Freehold Borough is the county seat of Monmouth County, a commuter town roughly midway between New York City and Philadelphia, and the surrounding Freehold Township is a larger, more suburban area with substantial preserved open space. The borough’s downtown is centered on the Monmouth County Courthouse and Main Street, giving it a small-town urban fabric, while the township is more car-dependent. The school itself is a neighborhood elementary school, and the district it belongs to covers both settings.
Academically, the state testing results in math and English language arts are a clear strength. In third grade, fourth grade, and fifth grade, the proportion of students scoring at or above the proficient level was well above half, and in every case the figure rose as students moved up through the grades. By fifth grade, the share of students meeting the state’s proficiency benchmark in English language arts was high, and in math it was similarly strong. When compared against all districts across Monmouth County, West Freehold’s overall proficiency index sits in the top quartile, meaning its students, as a group, are performing at a level that stands apart from the middle of the pack. That is a meaningful indicator for families looking for a school where a large majority of children are meeting grade-level expectations.
Science testing is a different story. The state administers science assessments at fifth grade, and here the proficiency rate fell well below what the school achieves in math and English. The parent may want to look into this further with the school. It is worth noting that science testing in New Jersey uses a different proficiency criteria than math and English, so the numbers are not directly comparable, but the gap is wide enough that a curious family would want to understand how science instruction is structured and whether the dip is a one-year pattern or something more persistent.
The student body is relatively homogeneous. A large majority of students are white, with a smaller share who are Hispanic, and even smaller shares who are Asian or Black. A modest share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which is a lower rate than what many New Jersey elementary schools see. The school does not report its count of students with disabilities or English learners in the data provided, so a family seeking a detailed picture of special education or English language support will need to ask the school directly.
The school is part of the Freehold Township School District, which in March 2025 passed a significant bond referendum to replace roofs, HVAC systems, fire alarms, and windows across all eight schools, and to create secure vestibules at every school. Two elementary schools, Applegate and Errickson, will also have their open pod-style classrooms converted to permanent walled classrooms. Work is expected to begin in the summer of 2026. That means West Freehold, like the other elementary buildings in the district, will see substantial facility improvements in the near future, funded through local property taxes.
Housing in the area reflects the region’s desirability. Typical home values put it in a range that is above the national median, and rental costs are similarly elevated. The area continues to see population growth, and the closure of the Freehold Raceway at the end of 2024 opens the possibility of redevelopment of that parcel, something families moving into the area may want to track.
What is missing from the available data is any information on class sizes, teacher experience, staff turnover, chronic absenteeism, discipline rates, or the school’s approach to curriculum and instruction. A family considering West Freehold will want to ask about those directly. Also absent is any breakdown of how student subgroups performed on state tests, so it is not possible to tell from this data whether the strong overall results are consistent across all groups or whether there are gaps.
For a family looking at elementary options in central Monmouth County, West Freehold presents as a school where academic proficiency in reading and math is well above the county average, where the building is likely to be updated in the coming years, and where the student population is not especially diverse economically or racially. The fifth-grade science results are a point worth investigating. The school serves only through fifth grade, so the next step for students is a middle school within the district, and families will need to look at those schools separately for a complete picture of the K-12 pathway.
See more original research from School Decision →