The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in Math. The lowest is 31% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Christopher Columbus School #8
Christopher Columbus School #8 is a regular public elementary school in Garfield, New Jersey, serving students from pre-kindergarten through fifth grade. It is one of several elementary schools within the Garfield Public School District, which operates in a densely populated, mixed-use city in Bergen County, about a dozen miles west of New York City. Garfield has a working-class and industrial heritage, a relatively young median age, and a diverse population. Housing values in the zip code are well above the national benchmark, with rents that have risen notably in the past year.
The student body at Columbus School #8 is about evenly split between Hispanic and white students, with a much smaller Black population representation. At least half of the students come from households with enough economic need to qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The enrollment covers a standard elementary age range, and the school does not serve grades that would produce a graduation rate, so that metric is not applicable here.
State testing results from the most recent year provide a mixed academic picture. In mathematics, proficiency rates climb by grade: the share of students meeting the state’s college-and-career-ready benchmark is modest in third grade, similar in fourth grade, and noticeably higher in fifth grade, where a solid majority of test-takers scored proficient. In English language arts, the pattern is less consistent. The third-grade proficiency rate is low, meaning a majority of third graders were not yet meeting the standard. Fourth graders performed substantially better, with a comfortable majority scoring proficient, but fifth graders dropped back to a level where fewer than half were proficient. In science, which is tested in fifth grade, about three in ten students met the standard. If a parent sees inconsistent results across grades like this, a question to explore with the school is how the curriculum or instruction differs between grade levels and what supports exist for students who enter below grade-level expectations.
When compared with other school districts in Bergen County, Columbus School #8’s overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quartile. That context places it on the lower end of a county that includes many high-performing districts. The school’s student population also reflects the shifting demographics of Garfield, a city that has grown in recent decades.
The school’s overall environment is shaped by its urban-suburban setting. Garfield is compact and densely built, with a grid of residential streets, commercial corridors, and community anchors like parks, a public library, and a recreation center. The district as a whole has at least one nationally recognized school: Washington Irving School #4 was named a National Blue Ribbon School in 2023, a signal of quality at one of its other elementary buildings.
A few key data points were not available. The school’s Title I status and disaggregated counts for students with disabilities and English learners were missing, which limits a full understanding of the student support landscape. Participation rates for state testing were also absent. Chronic absenteeism data was not reported, and no discipline or staffing information was present in the record. These gaps are common in many school profiles but are worth noting for a parent who wants to know about school climate and special education services. No information about extracurricular programs or course access was available for this school.
For a family considering Columbus School #8, the core takeaway is an elementary school in a dense, diverse community where academic proficiency moves around from grade to grade and sits below the county median. The school serves a large share of students from lower-income households, and the inconsistent test results across subjects and grade levels suggest a parent would benefit from asking the principal and classroom teachers about reading and math intervention strategies, how they support students who start behind, and whether the school has seen any recent curriculum or leadership changes. The broader Garfield district offers a range of elementary options, and Washington Irving’s Blue Ribbon award points to variation in performance across the system, which may be worth investigating.
See more original research from School Decision →