The top reported proficiency rate is 74% in Math. The lowest is 29% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Island Heights Elementary School
Island Heights Elementary School is a single K-6 public school that serves the small, historic borough of the same name in Ocean County. It is a regular public school, not a charter or magnet, and it is the only school in the Island Heights School District. Because it serves only through sixth grade, there is no graduation rate to report, and state testing covers grades three through six in math and English language arts, with science tested in grade five only.
On the New Jersey Student Learning Assessment, students at Island Heights Elementary post results that are strong in math and ELA, especially by the upper elementary years. In grade six, for example, nearly all students met the state’s proficiency bar in ELA, and a very large majority did so in math. Fourth and fifth graders also showed high proficiency rates in both subjects, while grade three numbers were somewhat lower but still exceeded a simple majority. The school’s overall proficiency index, which averages across tested subjects and grades, placed it in the top quarter of districts in Ocean County. That is a clear strength. Science results at grade five were an exception: about three in ten students reached proficiency. That is a sharp drop from the math and ELA figures, and a parent may want to ask the school how science instruction and curriculum are being addressed.
The school is small, with enrollment around a figure that would fill a modest elementary building. The student body is predominantly white, with a Hispanic share in the low double digits and a very small number of multiracial students. No Black or Asian students were reported. The share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch is very low, well below the county and state averages. That economic profile lines up with the borough’s housing market: home values in the area are well above the national median and sit near the state benchmark, reflecting a community that is largely owner-occupied and financially stable. Data on students with disabilities and English learners was not available, so those dimensions of support are not part of this picture.
Island Heights itself is a small residential borough on a bluff above the Toms River. It was founded as a Methodist camp meeting site and retains a historic character with Victorian-era cottages and a National Register Historic District. It is a dry town; alcohol cannot be sold. The land area is very small, and the population has seen a slow decline over recent decades with a modest recent uptick. The town has no major employers; residents likely commute to Toms River or beyond. Elementary students walk to a school that sits near the historic district center, while students in seventh through twelfth grades attend the Central Regional School District on a separate campus that serves several municipalities. The district itself is tiny and no major changes or referendums were found in recent years.
For a family considering Island Heights Elementary, the academic picture is one of strong math and reading outcomes through sixth grade, with a notable soft spot in elementary science that is worth investigating. The peer environment is economically homogenous and mostly white, which may be a factor for families seeking more diversity. The setting is quiet, historic, and tightly knit, with limited commercial activity and a slow-growth housing market. The school fits families who want a small, high-performing elementary in a stable, low-transiency community and who are comfortable with the regional arrangement for middle and high school.
See more original research from School Decision →