The top reported proficiency rate is 60% in English language arts. The lowest is 37% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Leonardo Elementary School
Leonardo Elementary is a small public school serving kindergarten through fifth grade in the unincorporated community of Leonardo, part of Middletown Township in Monmouth County. It sits within the Middletown Township Public School District, which operates multiple elementary schools feeding into a shared middle and high school pathway. Because the school ends at grade five, there is no graduation rate to report, and state testing data covers the grades that are assessed: third, fourth, and fifth in English language arts and math, with a fifth-grade science assessment.
The student body is predominantly White, with a much smaller share of Hispanic students and very small percentages of Black, Asian, multiracial, and Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander students. The share of students who qualify for free or reduced-price lunch is modest, suggesting a school community that is economically mixed but skews toward higher income compared to state averages. The school itself is small enough that each grade typically has around three to four classrooms, with enrollment balanced across the elementary years.
Academically, the school performs solidly. On the New Jersey Student Learning Assessments, a majority of students met or exceeded expectations in both English language arts and math across tested grades, placing the school’s overall proficiency above the midpoint when compared to other districts in Monmouth County. In English language arts, proficiency rates rose from third to fifth grade, with the strongest results at the fifth-grade level. Math proficiency was strongest in third grade and declined slightly in fourth and fifth, though still a majority of students in each grade scored proficient. Science results for fifth graders were softer: fewer than half of students reached the proficient threshold, a gap a parent may want to ask about, though science is tested less frequently and the proficiency bar is set differently from math and ELA. The school does not report chronic absenteeism or special education data in the public record, so those dimensions are not available to assess here.
The community around the school is a quiet, residential bayshore neighborhood. Leonardo is an unincorporated census-designated place with no downtown of its own; the school is embedded in the housing stock rather than set apart on a large campus. Route 36 runs along its southern edge, providing car access to nearby towns. The local housing market is moderately expensive, with home values above the national typical level and a median listing price in Monmouth County that reflects the broader coastal New Jersey premium. The population in Leonardo has been declining over the past two decades, and there is no sign of major new development. Families who live here tend to be homeowners, and the school draws from the immediate area rather than from a wide attendance zone.
Leonardo Elementary is a straightforward neighborhood school for families who value a small, stable elementary setting with a majority-proficient academic record. For those whose children struggle in a particular subject, especially science, the school’s support resources are not visible in the data, and a parent may want to ask about interventions directly. The lack of reported data on special education and English learner populations also means that families whose children need those services should inquire early about availability. Overall, the school fits a family looking for a solid academic foundation in a quiet, residential community where the elementary school is a short walk or drive from home.
See more original research from School Decision →