The top reported proficiency rate is 73% in Math. The lowest is 47% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Nut Swamp Elementary School
Nut Swamp Elementary School serves kindergarten through fifth grade as one of many neighborhood elementary schools within the Middletown Township Public School District, a large suburban system spread across nearly fifty-nine square miles in northern Monmouth County. The school is located in a residential area of the township, which functions as a bedroom community for commuters to New York City. Middletown has no single walkable downtown; its multiple distinct villages and neighborhoods — including Lincroft, Leonardo, Belford, Port Monmouth, Navesink, and Locust — give parents a range of housing settings to choose from, all feeding into the same district school system.
The student body is overwhelmingly white, with a modest Hispanic minority and small numbers of Asian and multiracial students. The share of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch is very low. This is a school where economic diversity among enrolled families is minimal; the low poverty rate aligns with the township's character as a largely upper-middle-income community where the median home value sits well above the national benchmark and the national price-to-income ratio is quite high. Housing in the area commands a premium, consistent with Monmouth County's generally elevated market.
On the New Jersey Student Learning Assessments, Nut Swamp posted proficiency rates that place the school in the top quarter of elementary schools in Monmouth County when looking at overall performance across tested subjects and grades. In math, results were consistently strong at every tested grade level, with the highest performance in fourth grade. English language arts results showed a wider spread. Third grade ELA proficiency came in lower than the other grades, a gap a parent may want to discuss with the school to understand how early literacy instruction and support are structured. By fourth and fifth grade, ELA rates rose considerably, pulling the school's overall English performance into a solid range. Science, tested in fifth grade only, showed fewer students reaching proficiency than in math or English, though the testing scale differs and requires a different proficiency threshold. Families who value strong academic foundations in elementary school will find Nut Swamp's core results generally reassuring, though the third-grade reading dip and the middle-of-the-road science showing are worth watching.
The school's enrollment is large for an elementary building that caps at fifth grade. Class sections appear to be well-populated. Because the school serves only elementary grades, there is no graduation rate and no high school course-access data to report; those metrics become relevant when students move on to the district's middle and high schools. The district itself did not yield publicly reported parent-relevant changes in recent searches, so the context at Nut Swamp appears stable.
For a family deciding whether Nut Swamp Elementary fits, the academic picture is strong with a clear emphasis on math and with ELA proficiency that improves across grade levels. The peer environment is economically and racially homogeneous. The broader housing market is expensive and competitive relative to national norms, and the township's commuter-oriented, car-dependent layout means daily life revolves around driving between its scattered neighborhoods. The school's steady results and low economic need profile suggest a setting with few of the resource challenges that sometimes occupy school leadership elsewhere. A parent who values a predictable, high-performing elementary experience in a town built for commuters will find Nut Swamp a straightforward match.
See more original research from School Decision →