The top reported proficiency rate is 17% in English language arts. The lowest is 8% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Paul W Carleton
Paul W. Carleton is a regular public elementary school in Penns Grove, New Jersey, serving only fourth and fifth grade within the Penns Grove-Carneys Point Regional School District. That narrow grade band means it functions as a bridge between the district’s primary schools and its middle school, a short but consequential stage in a student’s academic journey. The school is not a charter, magnet, or alternative program, so every family in the attendance zone moves through this building for those two years.
The student body is predominantly Hispanic and Black, with a smaller share of White students and very small numbers of Asian, multiracial, and Native American students. A substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a high-poverty context. That economic reality shapes the peer environment and the support structures families may need to seek out, though the available data does not include information on English learner or special education enrollment, which would give a fuller picture of the range of student needs.
State test results from the most recent year show that proficiency rates in math, English language arts, and science are below typical levels across New Jersey. In both fourth and fifth grade, the share of students meeting the state’s proficiency benchmark in math and ELA is well under a quarter, and fifth-grade science proficiency is lower still. Compared with other schools in Salem County, Paul W. Carleton’s overall proficiency index falls in the bottom quarter of districts. A parent looking at these numbers will want to ask the school directly about academic intervention programs, tiered support, and how the staff is working to move those percentages. The school’s small two-grade span may allow for targeted instruction, but the results suggest that catching students up or keeping them on grade level is a pressing challenge.
Penns Grove itself is a dense, compact borough on the Delaware River with a working-class, family-oriented character. The housing stock is older, property taxes are among the highest in New Jersey, and the population has been declining for decades, though there are signs of a commercial revival effort along Virginia Avenue. Housing values are noticeably lower than the statewide benchmark, which can make the area more accessible for buyers, but the tax burden is a trade-off. Many residents likely commute to Wilmington or Philadelphia for work. The borough has a traditional street grid and some local businesses, but it is not a high-amenity suburb; families should expect a modest, close-knit town environment.
No recent district-wide changes or strategic initiatives were publicly documented, so parents may want to check with the district office about curriculum updates, facility improvements, or any planned shifts in grade configuration. The school building is one of five in the district, and students at Paul W. Carleton will move on to Penns Grove Middle School for sixth grade, so the elementary experience here is a short but formative part of a longer pathway through the district.
For a family considering this school, the central facts are straightforward. The school serves a high-poverty, majority-minority student body in a community that is affordable but carries a high tax load. Academic achievement as measured by state tests is low relative to county peers, and a parent would want to understand how the school addresses that gap, what enrichment opportunities exist, and how the transition to middle school is managed. The school’s small grade span can be an advantage for focused instruction, but the underlying academic data gives a clear signal that extra attention may be needed.
See more original research from School Decision →