The top reported proficiency rate is 80% in English language arts. The lowest is 71% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Marshall Elementary School
Marshall Elementary School is a regular public school serving kindergarten through third grade in the South Orange-Maplewood School District, located in the village of South Orange, New Jersey. The school is small for its grade band, and its academic program is focused entirely on the early elementary years. Because it does not serve upper elementary, middle, or high school grades, there is no graduation rate or chronic absenteeism data to report, and no state testing results for grades beyond fourth. South Orange is a historic, primarily residential village that is both affluent and diverse. It is home to Seton Hall University, and its neighborhoods are known for tree-lined streets, gaslight street illumination, and a compact downtown along South Orange Avenue. The village has one of the larger Jewish communities in Essex County. South Orange and the adjacent town of Maplewood together form a single school district, so families moving into either community draw from the same set of elementary, middle, and high schools. Housing in the area is expensive, with a typical home in the village's ZIP code valued well above national levels, and rents are also high. The district has approved consecutive budgets with tax levy increases, meaning property tax growth has been running above the local trend in recent years and directly affects household costs.
The school's student body is predominantly white, with a Black or African American share of roughly a sixth and a Hispanic share of about a tenth. Students who identify as two or more races make up more than a tenth of enrollment. A small share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, which indicates that the student body comes from a comparatively high-income area. The school does not report data on students with disabilities or English learners, so a parent seeking information about support for those groups would need to ask the school directly.
On state testing, Marshall Elementary performed well relative to other schools in Essex County. The school landed in the top quarter of all district-level proficiency measures within the county. In third-grade English language arts, most students scored proficient or above. Third-grade math results were similarly strong. Fourth-grade results showed a slight drop in math proficiency compared to third grade, while fourth-grade English language arts remained strong. These are the only two tested grades at the school, and the picture is one of solid academic performance in the early primary years. A parent may want to look into the math dip between third and fourth grades, but the overall pattern is positive.
The district has made a major change to how elementary school assignments work. Its Intentional Integration Initiative, launched in 2020, redrew elementary school boundaries and buses students across all neighborhoods so that the socioeconomic makeup of each elementary school matches the district as a whole. The first cohort entered kindergarten in 2021. A lawsuit by some parents was filed in 2021 and settled in 2022, allowing the program to continue. This means families moving into the district cannot rely on a single neighborhood school assignment; instead, their child's elementary school placement is determined by a redistricting plan designed for socio-economic integration. Separately, voters rejected a school facilities bond in late 2022 that would have funded major renovations and additions across the district. The district has since developed a revised facilities plan focused on essential maintenance rather than large-scale construction, so the physical condition of school buildings may not see the level of investment that was originally proposed.
For a family considering Marshall Elementary, the core offer is a small, early-grades-only school with strong academic results in a high-cost, suburban village with an active university presence and a district that has intentionally restructured its elementary attendance zones. The school's performance on state tests is a clear strength. The student body is economically advantaged by the share qualifying for meal assistance. The district's tax trajectory, the failed bond referendum, and the redistricting plan are all features of the context that a parent would want to weigh directly with the district office, as they affect both school conditions and the cost of living.
See more original research from School Decision →