The top reported proficiency rate is 50% in Math. The lowest is 47% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Mahala F. Atchison School
Mahala F. Atchison School serves children from pre-kindergarten through second grade in Tinton Falls, a large suburban borough in eastern Monmouth County. As one of three schools in the Tinton Falls School District, it is an early elementary building; students move on to another school for later elementary grades and then to a district middle school. Because the school covers only the youngest grades, families should know that many of the data points that typically appear for older schools — such as a graduation rate, chronic absenteeism rates, or state testing results beyond third grade — do not apply here or are not available.
Tinton Falls is a car-dependent community bisected by the Garden State Parkway and Route 18. It lacks a walkable downtown core; instead, residential subdivisions and commercial corridors dominate the landscape, including the Jersey Shore Premium Outlets. The borough is also home to corporate headquarters like Commvault Systems and large institutional land uses such as Naval Weapons Station Earle. The school itself sits on Sycamore Avenue, a road that runs through the small historic village district at the intersection with Tinton Avenue. Housing in the area is expensive, with home values well above national and state medians and rents that absorb a notable share of household income. The borough has seen steady population growth over recent decades, though large tracts of land occupied by military and county facilities constrain new development. Median household income is high, and the population skews older, consistent with an established suburban profile.
At Atchison, enrollment is modest for a PK-2 building. Most students are white, with smaller shares of Hispanic, Black, Asian, and multiracial students. About one in seven students qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, a low share that reflects the borough's relative affluence. Data on students with disabilities and English learners were not reported in the available records, so a family with a child in either group may want to ask the school directly about services and supports.
The only state assessment results available date back more than a decade, from the 2014-15 school year, when third graders took the PARCC exams. At that time, about half of the tested students met the state's proficiency standard in both math and English language arts. When compared with other districts in Monmouth County, that performance level falls below the midpoint. Because this is a single snapshot from a long-ago testing cycle and newer data is absent, these results offer a very limited picture of current academic performance. The school serves grades that are not tested until third grade, so families may find it hard to gauge ongoing student progress through the early years with the data publicly available.
No information was provided on course offerings, staffing levels, discipline rates, or attendance. There is also no indication of specialized programs such as magnet or Title I status. The district search turned up little in the way of recent strategic changes or notable developments.
For a family considering this school, the main takeaway is that Atchison is a small, early-grades building in a well-off suburban community with high housing costs. The academic snapshot is dated and thin, and broader school environment data is missing. A parent would likely want to visit, speak with staff about current instruction and supports, and understand how the district measures early learning outcomes beyond the old state test.
See more original research from School Decision →