Original Research by School Decision on Robert D Reynolds Primary School
Robert D Reynolds Primary School is a regular public school serving prekindergarten through second grade in Upper Saddle River, a borough in Bergen County. Because it covers only the earliest elementary years, the school does not participate in state testing—those assessments begin in third grade—so there are no proficiency or growth data to review here. Parents looking at this school will be evaluating it on environment and programming rather than on standardized academic outcomes, which are years away for its students.
Upper Saddle River is a low-density suburban community of one-acre lots, with high household incomes that rank among the top in New Jersey. The borough remained largely rural until the 1950s, when suburban development multiplied its population, and growth has been stable ever since. There is no traditional downtown; civic buildings and the district’s three schools are spread through the residential neighborhoods. Commerce is concentrated along Route 17 on the borough’s western edge. The Saddle River bisects the town, and major highways including the Garden State Parkway are a short drive away; there is no passenger rail in the borough. The North American headquarters of Hunter Douglas is located here, but the departure of Pearson Education in recent years reduced local employment, reinforcing Upper Saddle River’s character as a bedroom community.
The student body at Reynolds is small for a school serving these grades. Enrollment is predominantly white, with a substantial Asian cohort and a smaller Hispanic share; Black, Native Hawaiian or Pacific Islander, and multiracial students make up the remainder. Very few students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the borough’s high-income profile. Data on students with disabilities and English learners were not available; a parent may want to ask the school directly about special education services and language support for this age group.
Because Reynolds is a primary school, the district pathway matters. Students move to Edith A Bogert Elementary School for third through fifth grade, then to Emil A Cavallini Middle School for sixth through eighth, and finally to Northern Highlands Regional High School in Allendale, a separate campus that also serves Allendale and Ho-Ho-Kus. Parents considering Reynolds should be comfortable with this progression and with travel to a high school outside the borough.
The housing market in Upper Saddle River is among the most expensive in Bergen County. Homes on one-acre lots command very high prices, and the supply of listings is tight relative to demand. Median listing prices in the county are well above national and state benchmarks, and the typical mortgage payment on a median-priced home here is high. Rents, where they exist, are also elevated. This is a community where homeownership is the norm and affordability is a real consideration for any family moving in.
The district itself has been stable in recent years. A search for significant referendums, bond issues, curriculum changes, or property-tax shifts turned up no lasting changes to report. The school’s operational status is open, and it is classified as a regular school. No program offerings or extended learning opportunities were listed in the available data, so parents should contact the school to learn about enrichment, early childhood offerings, and any before- or after-care arrangements.
Robert D Reynolds Primary School serves a small, economically homogeneous population in a high-cost suburban setting. It is the entry point to a tiered district that ends at a regional high school. Because state testing data do not apply to these grades, the main considerations for families are the community’s character, the size and composition of the peer group, and whether the borough’s housing market and school pathway fit their plans.
See more original research from School Decision →