The top reported proficiency rate is 97% in Social studies. The lowest is 31% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Ps 30 Hernandez/hughes
PS 30 Hernandez/Hughes sits on East 128th Street in Harlem, a pre-K through fifth grade public elementary school in New York City Geographic District 5. Its enrollment is small for a school spanning that many grade levels, and its student body is almost entirely Black and Hispanic, with the vast majority of students qualifying for free or reduced-price lunch. That demographic picture reflects the school's deep roots in a historically working-class Harlem neighborhood rather than any judgment about the school's quality or direction.
The neighborhood itself is dense, walkable, and embedded in the transit fabric of Manhattan. Subway lines connect families to jobs and institutions across the city without a car, and the street-level mix of residential buildings, small businesses, and community spaces is characteristic of upper Manhattan. Housing costs in the school's zip code are well above the state median and have held close to that level even as recent data shows a slight year-over-year dip in home values; rents have risen over the past year. For families considering whether to plant roots here, the housing market is expensive relative to New York State as a whole and dramatically above national norms.
On state assessments, the academic picture is mixed and worth reading carefully. The tested grades are third, fourth, and fifth. In English language arts, fourth and fifth grade results are genuinely strong, with most tested students reaching proficiency in both grades; third grade ELA is weaker, with under half proficient. Math results run lower across the board. Third and fourth grade math proficiency sits at roughly a third of tested students, and fifth grade improves but still leaves about half of students below proficient. Fifth grade science results are the weakest measured area, with fewer than a third of students reaching proficiency. Taken together, the school's overall proficiency index across subjects and grades sits just above the midpoint among schools in the comparison set of districts within New York County, which means it is not among the stronger performers in a highly competitive county, but it is not at the bottom either.
One interpretive caution: the tested groups are small. With only a handful of students per grade sitting for each exam, a few students in either direction can shift a proficiency rate substantially. That does not make the numbers meaningless, but it means a parent should not read a single year's result as a fixed ceiling or floor. Multi-year trend data was not available in the data provided, so it is not possible to say whether these results represent improvement, decline, or stability over time. That would be a good question to raise directly with the school.
Data on IEP rates and English learner populations was not reported, so it is not clear what share of students receive special education services or language support, both of which can matter considerably when evaluating fit for a child with those needs.
Two systemwide policy changes affect every family evaluating District 5 elementary schools. Under the publicly reported NYC Reads mandate, all elementary schools are now required to teach reading using one of three phonics-based curricula, replacing the prior approach where principals chose their own materials. Families who care about the science of reading or who have children who struggled with earlier approaches may find this shift worth discussing with the school. The city has also restructured middle and high school admissions, including restored academic screens at the middle school level and expanded citywide access, which is relevant for families thinking about where PS 30's graduates will land after fifth grade.
A graduation rate is not applicable here because the school serves only pre-K through fifth grade. No program offerings data was included in what was provided, so extracurriculars, arts, or enrichment specifics were left out rather than guessed.
See more original research from School Decision →