The top reported proficiency rate is 67% in Social studies. The lowest is 16% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Ps 154 Harriet Tubman
PS 154 Harriet Tubman is a small public elementary school in Upper Manhattan serving PreK through grade five. The school sits on West 127th Street in a densely built, heavily residential neighborhood near City College and the uptown corridor. Like many New York City public schools, it is embedded within the urban block fabric rather than on a separate campus; the building is a standard mixed-use city structure integrated into street life.
The school's student body is nearly homogeneous by design and circumstance. The enrollment is roughly split between Black and Hispanic students, with Black students comprising the majority. An overwhelming share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting deep economic need in the neighborhood. Enrollment is small for the grade band, with only a handful of students per grade, which shapes both the peer environment and the school's ability to offer depth in programming.
State test data for the 2024-25 school year shows mixed results across grades and subjects. In third-grade math and English language arts, roughly half the tested students reached proficiency. Fourth-grade math was noticeably stronger, with a substantial share proficient. Fifth grade represented a significant drop: fewer than a third of students were proficient in math, and similar proportions in English language arts. In science, tested only at grade five, fewer than one in five students achieved proficiency. This grade-to-grade pattern, with fourth grade performing meaningfully better than third and fifth, suggests inconsistent academic momentum or possible cohort variation rather than a school-wide baseline. A parent evaluating this school may want to ask how the school accounts for the sharp decline in the upper grades and what support systems address struggling students.
The school operates under New York City's reading and math curriculum mandates now in effect across the district. All elementary schools, including PS 154, must use one of three approved phonics-based reading programs (Into Reading, Wit & Wisdom, or EL Education). This removes curricular choice from individual schools but provides a common literacy framework aligned with the science of reading. These systemwide mandates are relatively new and worth understanding in terms of how they align with your own views on reading instruction.
The school's immediate neighborhood is walkable, dense, and mixed-use, with ground-floor retail and restaurants alongside residential buildings. Public transit access is extensive; the upper Manhattan subway lines connect the area to the rest of the city. Housing in the 10027 zip code reflects the city's sustained production of new units and overall housing-market strength, though the economic profile of the school's families suggests affordability remains a major constraint for most households.
Limited data was available on the school's staffing, attendance patterns, discipline practices, or specialized programs such as English learner services or special education. The school does not report its own specialized population counts, which is typical for smaller schools or those serving populations below certain reporting thresholds. Families interested in these specifics should ask the school directly about class size, teacher experience, support services, and any specialized offerings.
Across the five tested grades and four subjects, the school's overall proficiency index sits below the midpoint when compared with other elementary schools in the county, a factual positioning that reflects the test scores reported above. The pattern of strongest results in fourth grade and weakest in fifth is the most concrete signal available about where instruction is most effective.
See more original research from School Decision →