The top reported proficiency rate is 32% in English language arts. The lowest is 3% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on New Design Middle School
New Design Middle School is a small, traditionally organized public middle school serving grades six through eight in upper Manhattan. It enrolls a compact cohort drawn almost entirely from families with low income and families of color: nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the enrollment is split evenly between Black and Hispanic students, with a small white minority. The school sits at 625 W 133rd Street, in a dense, mixed-use neighborhood where residents navigate life largely by subway and foot.
Test results show a school in difficulty across both math and English language arts. In math, proficiency is minimal: no sixth graders reached proficiency on the 2024-25 state assessment, and seventh and eighth grade numbers are in the low single digits. English language arts scores are stronger but still low, ranging from around one quarter to around two fifths of students meeting the state's proficiency standard across the three grade levels. A small cohort took the grade-eight science test, and proficiency there was similarly low. These are materials a parent would want to examine closely and discuss with the school. A family considering this school should ask directly about what the school is doing to address these gaps, what curriculum and instruction look like in core subjects, and what support structures exist for students who arrive behind.
The school is part of New York City Geographic District 5, which spans a large area of Manhattan including parts of upper Manhattan. Like all New York City schools, New Design participates in the district's curriculum mandates: the NYC Reads literacy initiative requires all elementary schools to use one of three approved phonics-based reading curricula (though this school serves only middle grades, this policy shapes the preparation students bring when they enter sixth grade), and the NYC Solves initiative is rolling out approved math programs across middle schools through 2027. The district also restructured admissions starting in 2024: middle schools can now use academic screens at superintendent discretion, families may apply citywide while keeping in-district priority, and high school applicants face no cap on choice count.
The housing market in this part of Manhattan is active. Home values in the neighborhood are modest compared to much of the city, and rents remain substantial but less severe than in many other New York City zip codes. The neighborhood itself is walkable and transit-rich, with the subway providing access to jobs, cultural life, and other city resources. The area is experiencing sustained housing growth, part of a broader citywide development push that has accelerated through 2024 and into 2025. The immediate surroundings are densely mixed-use, with residential and commercial space intermingled, small- and large-scale buildings side by side, and streets active with pedestrians and vehicles.
New Design serves one of the city's most economically stressed student populations. The concentration of need here is among the highest in the school system. No data on English learner status or students with disabilities was available, so a parent evaluating the school should ask about the availability of language support and special education services. The school's small enrollment, while it may mean closer relationships between students and staff, also means fewer course sections and potentially less elective breadth than larger schools offer. Program information beyond the standard middle school curriculum was not available in the data.
A parent considering New Design should schedule a visit, review the school's current initiatives to raise proficiency in math and reading, and understand what the school's plan is for supporting students entering with academic gaps. The test results signal that this school faces real instructional challenges; the question for a family is whether the school's approach, staff, and support systems match what their child needs.
See more original research from School Decision →