The top reported proficiency rate is 53% in Social studies. The lowest is 20% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Ps 18 John Peter Zenger
PS 18 John Peter Zenger is a small, PreK through fifth-grade public school in the South Bronx serving a tight-knit, economically vulnerable student body. Situated on Morris Avenue in a neighborhood in the midst of substantial housing and infrastructure growth, the school faces notable academic challenges that a parent should understand clearly.
The student body is predominantly Hispanic, with a significant Black student population. Nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic stress of the surrounding neighborhood. The school draws families from a densely populated area where new affordable housing is being built at scale, including major projects like Fordham Landing South and La Central, so enrollment may reflect shifting neighborhood composition over time.
Academically, PS 18's state test results are weak across all tested grades and subjects. In third grade, roughly a quarter of students met proficiency in both math and English language arts. Fourth grade showed modest improvement, with proficiency near thirty percent in both subjects. Fifth grade declined notably in math but held closer to thirty percent in ELA, while science proficiency fell to around twenty percent. These results place the school in the bottom quartile for overall proficiency when compared to other districts in Bronx County. A parent may want to look into this further with the school, particularly if early literacy and numeracy growth matter deeply to your family's educational approach.
The school participates in NYC Reads, the citywide shift to phonics-based literacy instruction that began rolling out in 2023 and reached full implementation in 2024. This means every elementary classroom at PS 18 now uses one of three city-approved, evidence-based reading curricula centered on structured phonics, a substantial change from the balanced literacy model many schools used before. The intent is to strengthen foundational reading skills from the start.
District 7, the geographic district that includes PS 18, also gained the South Bronx Literacy Academy, a new school specifically designed for students with dyslexia and other reading disabilities, using Orton-Gillingham structured-literacy instruction with small classes, embedded specialists, and extended reading time. This is a resource families in the area can access by lottery if their child struggles with reading disabilities.
The broader South Bronx neighborhood is in active transformation. Housing values and rents in the 10451 zip code are appreciating, and the South Bronx is receiving major investment in both affordable housing and infrastructure. If you are considering this school as part of a longer-term housing decision, the neighborhood's momentum toward density and new construction is real, though it is also reshaping what the area's economic and social fabric looks like. Schools in neighborhoods undergoing rapid change sometimes experience shifts in enrollment and community composition over a few years.
If your family prioritizes a small, neighborhood-embedded early elementary experience with strong ties to the local community, PS 18 is that. If early academic acceleration or above-grade-level performance in math and reading is a key priority, the evidence here suggests you would want to explore other options or have a detailed conversation with the school about how they support students who arrive reading or computing ahead of grade level. The school's participation in NYC Reads offers a clear, structured pathway for reading instruction, which may matter if your child learns best with explicit, sequential phonics.
See more original research from School Decision →