The top reported proficiency rate is 20% in Social studies. The lowest is 14% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Ms 301 Paul L Dunbar
MS 301 Paul L Dunbar is a small, six-through-eight middle school in the Bronx serving the neighborhoods around Cauldwell Avenue in the South Bronx. The school enrolls a compact group of students, with roughly equal numbers across the three grades, and the student body is almost entirely economically disadvantaged. Nearly all students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student composition is predominantly Hispanic and Black, with a small presence of American Indian and Alaskan Native students.
The school's state test results show consistent weakness across literacy and mathematics. In grade six, proficiency in English language arts sits in the single digits, while math proficiency is in the low twenties. Grade seven marks a sharp decline: math proficiency drops to near zero, and ELA proficiency hovers in the low teens. By grade eight, where the school administers science testing alongside literacy and math, performance improves modestly. ELA proficiency reaches the low thirties, math climbs to the mid-twenties, and science proficiency sits in the low teens. Across all subjects and grades, the proficiency index places the school in the bottom quartile relative to other districts in Bronx County. Test participation rates are generally strong, with most grades at or above ninety percent of students taking the assessments.
The school sits within New York City Geographic District 8, which serves parts of the South and Central Bronx. District 8 has implemented major curriculum mandates under the city's NYC Reads and NYC Solves initiatives. Beginning in September 2025, middle schools in the district adopted a standardized math curriculum (Amplify Desmos Math) and literacy program (part of the NYC Reads expansion), changes that affect how students in grades six through eight are taught. District 8 has also experienced sustained enrollment decline since the middle of the prior decade, with middle school enrollment down by more than a portion of its prior volume, reflecting both fewer school-aged residents in the neighborhoods served and migration of students to charter schools. The district operates with substantial excess middle school seats.
The immediate neighborhood sits in the South Bronx, an area in transition. The Bronx overall is experiencing significant new housing development, with investment in affordable apartments, transit-oriented waterfront projects like Fordham Landing South, and expanded Metro-North service planned through new stations. The broader borough landscape mixes dense apartment corridors with leafy residential enclaves; the South Bronx neighborhoods are characterized by commercial spines, elevated structures, and brick-and-stone building stock. The area around the school is walkable, with access to local retail and services, though the neighborhood is not among the city's most affluent. Housing values in the school's zip code are notably below the New York State benchmark.
Families considering this school face a direct question about academic recovery. The state testing results show most students are not proficient in core subjects, particularly in math. A parent may want to explore with the school what academic support structures are in place, what the trajectory of improvement looks like, and how the school's curriculum rollout is being implemented for the current year. The small size could be an asset for close relationships with staff; the economic need is acute. The data sections carry the specific test figures and enrollment numbers; the prose here aims to ground what they mean for a student pathway and peer environment. This is a school serving high-need neighborhoods with low current proficiency outcomes.
See more original research from School Decision →