Original Research by School Decision on Astor Collegiate Academy
Astor Collegiate Academy is a public high school in the northeast Bronx serving grades nine through twelve. The school enrolls a school population that is majority Hispanic and Black, with a substantial Asian student population and representation from other groups. A large share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing the school in a neighborhood and student demographic context of economic need.
The school's enrollment runs across all four high school grades, with the largest classes in the ninth and tenth grades. The ninth-grade cohort appears notably larger than the graduating senior class, a pattern that may reflect typical high school attrition, transitions to alternative settings, or other factors a parent may want to look into directly with the school.
State testing data for Astor Collegiate Academy was not available, so we could not assess how students perform on New York's standardized assessments relative to the school or county benchmarks. A graduation rate was also not provided in the available data. Without these measures, a parent cannot compare the school's academic outcomes to its peer institutions or track how completers leave the school. This gap is notable; a parent considering this school would benefit from requesting these metrics directly from the school or the district office.
The school sits within Geographic District 11 in New York City, which serves portions of the Bronx. Like all NYC high schools, Astor Collegiate Academy is subject to the NYC Solves math initiative, under which nearly all city high schools adopted the Illustrative Mathematics curriculum for Algebra 1, emphasizing conceptual understanding over procedural steps. The district has also adopted standardized literacy interventions beginning in the 2025-26 school year to support struggling readers, a development that will shape how the school serves students reading below grade level. These curriculum mandates are systemwide and affect teaching and learning in all NYC high schools.
The broader Bronx context includes strong growth in housing and development. The Astor Avenue location sits in the northeast Bronx, an area with parks, transit access via MTA bus and subway lines, and walkable commercial streets. Housing values in the zip code have been moving upward, and rental costs have risen. Health care, led by Montefiore Medical Center, anchors the local economy, alongside city employment, nonprofits, and smaller commercial enterprises. The Bronx is experiencing substantial new affordable housing development, with major projects breaking ground and zoning changes opening paths for denser, mixed-income construction.
Astor Collegiate Academy has enrollment that is manageable and not particularly small for a high school in an urban district. The concentration of students in the lower grades and the drop-off toward twelfth grade is something a prospective family should clarify with school leadership. A parent seeking to understand this school's academic standing, college readiness outcomes, and graduation pathway would be well served by speaking with the school directly about test results, college placement, career and technical offerings, and how the school supports students through completion and transition to post-secondary life.
See more original research from School Decision →