The top reported proficiency rate is 73% in Social studies. The lowest is 39% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Ps 54 Hillside
PS 54 Hillside sits on 127th Street in Richmond Hill, a dense, tree-lined southwestern Queens neighborhood whose residential blocks of frame houses and brick rowhomes give way to active commercial corridors on Jamaica Avenue and Liberty Avenue. The school serves kindergarten through fifth grade within NYC Geographic District 28, a large district covering this stretch of Queens.
The student body is predominantly Hispanic, with a meaningful Asian presence and smaller shares of Black, white, and other students. The vast majority of enrolled children qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, placing this squarely in the economically high-need tier of New York City elementary schools. Data on English learner identification rates and students with IEPs were not available in what was provided.
State testing results from the most recent year show a varied picture across grades and subjects. Third-grade math proficiency is clearly a strength, with most tested students reaching the proficient level, well above what many comparable schools produce. Third and fourth grade ELA results are also solid, with roughly two-thirds of tested students at or above proficiency in both grades. Fifth grade results are softer across the board: math proficiency drops to roughly half of tested students, ELA to a bit under two-thirds, and fifth-grade science proficiency falls below half. That science result in particular is worth a conversation with the school, since it reflects a substantial share of fifth graders not yet reaching the tested standard. Placed against other schools in Queens County districts, PS 54's overall proficiency index lands above the midpoint of that comparison set, which is a meaningful position given the economic context of the enrollment.
One technical note: participation rates in grades three and four were meaningfully below the state's target threshold. When a notable share of students in a grade do not sit for the state exam, proficiency figures can shift depending on who was and was not tested, so parents should keep that in mind when reading those grade-level results.
Trend data was not available, so it is not possible to characterize whether these results represent improvement, stability, or decline over prior years.
District 28 is now operating under the NYC Reads mandate, which publicly reported sources describe as a lasting, systemwide shift to literacy instruction aligned with the science of reading. All District 28 elementary schools, including PS 54, were required to adopt one of three city-approved reading curriculums beginning in the 2024-25 school year. The mandate has been sustained by city leadership even after some adjustments to teacher pacing flexibility. For parents who have opinions about how reading is taught, this is the context they are entering. Separately, the district's Gifted and Talented program has been restructured to include a third-grade entry point with a broader screening approach, which affects families thinking about accelerated programming options as their children move through elementary school. Looking further ahead, Queens High School for the Sciences, the borough's selective specialized high school, is publicly reported to be relocating into District 28 with expanded capacity, which is relevant context for families thinking about the longer academic pathway.
Richmond Hill itself is highly walkable by New York standards, with the J and Z trains running above Jamaica Avenue and multiple bus routes threading the neighborhood. Forest Park borders the neighborhood to the north, offering green space, trails, and fields that are otherwise rare in this part of Queens. The housing market near the school is expensive relative to state and national benchmarks, with home values and rents both rising year-over-year, a pattern consistent with broader Queens pressure that has spurred city rezoning efforts to concentrate new development along Jamaica Avenue while protecting the interior residential blocks.
Program-specific details for PS 54, such as enrichment offerings, after-school programs, or staffing ratios, were not included in the data provided. Families interested in those specifics would want to ask the school directly.
See more original research from School Decision →