The top reported proficiency rate is 52% in English language arts. The lowest is 31% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Harlem Children's Zone Promise Academy Ii Charter School
Harlem Children's Zone Promise Academy II is a charter school serving kindergarten through twelfth grade from two locations in East Harlem: an elementary campus that opened in its current building in early 2023, and a middle and high school campus several blocks away. The school is part of a broader community-development organization and enrolls a substantial number of students, nearly all of whom qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is predominantly Black, with a meaningful Hispanic enrollment and very small numbers of students of other racial backgrounds.
In English language arts, the school shows mixed performance across grades. Proficiency is strongest in third grade, where about two-thirds of tested students reached proficiency, but drops significantly in fourth and sixth grades, where it falls below half. Performance rises again in seventh and eighth grades, reaching the mid-50s. Math proficiency follows a similar pattern: strong in third grade and substantially higher in grades seven and eight, but notably weaker in the elementary grades, particularly in grades three, four, and six. Grade five outperforms its adjacent grades in both subjects. Science testing, available for grades five and eight, shows a particular soft spot: only about a fifth of fifth graders and two-fifths of eighth graders reached proficiency. Across subjects and grades, overall proficiency sits below the midpoint relative to other districts in New York County.
The school shows solid test participation rates, particularly in the middle grades where participation exceeds ninety percent. Third grade participation in math and English is somewhat lower, though still substantial. This consistency in participation suggests that gaps in proficiency are not driven by absent or excluded students but reflect actual performance differences.
The school operates in an intensely urban, mixed-use neighborhood where schools are embedded within dense block fabric rather than sited on separated campuses. Public transit is extensive and heavily used, and the area benefits from the walkability characteristic of Manhattan. The surrounding housing market reflects citywide growth, with home values and rents notably higher than national benchmarks, characteristic of New York City real estate. Nearby employers span finance, technology, and large service-sector firms; tech hiring is expanding faster than other sectors.
The school's enrollment in middle and high school grades declines noticeably from the elementary pipeline, suggesting either attrition or outflow as students reach secondary grades, a pattern a parent may want to look into further with the school. The specific reasons for this grade-level shift, and whether it reflects student choice, performance-driven transitions, or other factors, would be worth clarifying. Graduation rate data was not available, so it is unclear what share of ninth graders complete the high school program.
The Promise Academy model emphasizes both academic rigor and community wraparound supports, and the relocation of elementary classes to a purpose-built facility in 2023 reflects institutional investment in physical infrastructure and expanded capacity. For families seeking a charter option in East Harlem with a comprehensive K-12 pathway, this school offers a long-term enrollment trajectory. However, the gaps in early elementary math proficiency and the particularly weak performance in elementary and middle school science are real weaknesses worth understanding before enrollment, whether through conversations with school leadership about instructional approaches, recent curriculum changes, or longer-term trend data.
See more original research from School Decision →