The top reported proficiency rate is 73% in Math. The lowest is 64% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on John F Kennedy Elementary School
John F Kennedy Elementary School serves kindergarten through second grade in Brewster, a very small, dense village in Putnam County that sits astride Metro-North's Harlem Line and is the most densely populated part of the county. The school enrollment is concentrated in the early grades: the building contains roughly equal numbers of kindergarteners and first graders, with a somewhat larger second-grade cohort. About two in five students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The student body is ethnically diverse, with Hispanic students making up slightly more than half the enrollment and white students about two in five; smaller numbers of Asian, Black, and multiracial students also attend.
State testing data is available only for grade three, which tests just outside the school's grade span. The most recent results on record, from the 2011-12 school year, showed proficiency in mathematics noticeably above six in ten students and in English language arts around six in ten, with average scale scores solid in both areas. A parent looking for a current academic snapshot should ask the school directly about recent achievement, since state testing results for grades within this school's band are not publicly reported.
The Brewster Central School District recently adopted substantial curriculum changes at the elementary level that affect how reading, math, and science are taught. Literacy instruction now uses ARC Core, a science-of-reading program available in both monolingual and dual-language tracks, paired with systematic phonics and word study. Math in Focus, grounded in concrete-pictorial-abstract progression, replaces earlier approaches for kindergarten through grade five. Elementary science shifted to Project Lead the Way for grades two through five. These are meaningful pedagogical shifts, and a parent should understand the district's rationale and how the school is supporting students through the transition.
Brewster itself is undergoing rapid change. A major transit-oriented redevelopment project called Brewster Crossing is planned to reshape the downtown near the village center with mixed-use buildings, retail, and residential space; first phase completion is expected by 2027. The redevelopment has generated community discussion about historic preservation and the pace of change. Housing values in the area are moderate relative to the state benchmark but notably higher than the national median, and home prices have risen modestly year over year. Mortgage rates and inflation in housing costs are relevant facts for families considering the area.
The district approved substantial capital improvements in a 2023 referendum, including infrastructure upgrades across all buildings, a new turf field and track, security enhancements, a new cafetorium and classroom space at the intermediate school, and a field house and STEAM lab at the high school. These multi-year projects will reshape school facilities families encounter as their children advance through the grades. The district's 2025-26 budget proposed a restrained property tax increase well below the state cap, aided by growth in state and federal aid, a relevant data point for families weighing tax burden.
State testing data specific to the school's own grade band was not available, so a parent may want to ask the school directly about current reading, math, and science proficiency, how students are progressing with the new curricula, and what supports are in place for students who are struggling or for English learners. Enrollment counts for special education and English learner services were not reported; asking the school about the availability and design of these programs is warranted.
See more original research from School Decision →