The top reported proficiency rate is 63% in Math. The lowest is 40% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on South Side Elementary School
South Side Elementary School serves second and third grade students in Canastota, a small Madison County village anchored by historic downtown commercial districts and the restored Erie Canal. The school is part of Canastota Central School District, which operates four schools clustered near the village center. South Side sits at the corner of High and Roberts Streets, a short distance from the historic downtown and its walkable civic core of libraries, museums, and restored canal-front spaces.
The school serves a student body of about midsize for its grade band. A substantial portion of students qualify for free or reduced-price meals, reflecting economic patterns in this region where employment sectors concentrate in health care, educational services, and transportation and warehousing. The student population is largely white, with smaller numbers of multiracial students. Data on special education and English learner populations was not available.
In mathematics, the school's proficiency rates sit above the county median. Third-grade students showed solid ground, with about three-fifths meeting proficiency standards; fourth-grade results were slightly stronger, with about two-thirds proficient. Reading and language arts performance is notably weaker than mathematics across both tested grades. Third-grade results in English language arts fell below half proficient, and fourth-grade performance dropped further, with about one-third of students meeting state proficiency standards. Overall, the school's proficiency index sits above the midpoint among Madison County districts, but the gap between mathematics and reading suggests that literacy development may warrant parent attention and conversation with classroom teachers about support strategies at home.
The district recently secured voter approval for a capital authorization increase to fund facilities work, signaling ongoing building improvement. For the 2025-26 school year, the district proposed a property tax increase above the regional average, driven by rising health insurance costs and other budget pressures. Families considering the Canastota district should factor this higher-than-average levy into their housing and relocation plans.
Canastota itself is in an active revitalization phase. The village received substantial state funding through the New York Forward program to support downtown mixed-use development, including new affordable housing units and canal-front amenities. The Oneida Indian Nation, a major regional economic anchor, has completed workforce housing projects nearby. Downtown streetscape improvements over recent years have restored historic character, with new lighting, benches, and storefronts supporting local dining and community gathering. Most residents drive for work and daily life is car-dependent, though the restored Erie Canal and adjacent Empire State Trail offer recreation and walking access to the water. Housing values in the area have shown modest appreciation and remain below state and national benchmarks, making the market relatively affordable for buyers entering the region.
See more original research from School Decision →