The top reported proficiency rate is 79% in Math. The lowest is 70% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Cazenovia High School
Cazenovia High School serves middle and high school grades in a small historic lakeside village in Madison County, about half an hour from Syracuse. The school sits on Emory Avenue within the compact village, a short walk from downtown's commercial core, in a setting where civic life is concentrated around a walkable center rather than dispersed across campus sprawl.
The school enrolls roughly mid-sized numbers of students across grades eight through twelve. The student body is predominantly white, with a modest diversity profile. About a quarter of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating a range of family incomes within a largely suburban and rural district. The school does not report counts for students with individualized education plans or English learners, data gaps that a parent might ask the school about directly.
On state testing, the school's eighth-grade cohort shows proficiency rates in the upper range of performance. Math proficiency sits above three-quarters of students meeting or exceeding standards, English language arts reaches about three-quarters, and science proficiency is somewhat lower at around seventy percent. These results place the school in the top quartile for overall proficiency when compared to other districts in Madison County. That said, participation rates for math and science testing were notably lower than for English language arts, which a parent may want to look into further with the school; the district does not report results for high school grades, so secondary student achievement cannot be assessed from state testing data.
The school operates within a district that has faced repeated budget pressures. Both the 2024-25 and 2025-26 budgets initially failed because proposed tax levy increases would have exceeded New York's property tax cap, requiring supermajority approval. Revised, lower-levy versions passed after the initial rejections. This pattern reflects fiscal strain common to districts with below-average state aid relative to community wealth, and it affects staffing, program capacity, and the year-to-year stability families experience. Voters have rejected or required revision of budgets in multiple recent years.
A substantial facilities upgrade arrived in October 2024 when the district opened a new Emory Avenue Athletic Complex with two synthetic turf fields and a track-ready high school stadium. This project, approved by referendum, will be visible to families prioritizing athletics and outdoor physical education.
The district also operates a free, full-day Universal Pre-Kindergarten program five days a week on the elementary calendar, a benefit for families with younger children.
The village economy is anchored in education, hospitality, and health care. A significant shift underway is the redevelopment of the former Cazenovia College campus, which closed in 2023 and sat vacant until local investors agreed to transform it into an innovation and community district with office space, retail, dining, and new housing. That project is expected to unfold over several years and will reshape the downtown character and demographic profile of the town.
Housing values in the Cazenovia zip code sit above both state and national medians, placing homeownership within reach for families with above-average income but requiring substantial monthly mortgage commitment. Rental housing, though less available, is similarly positioned above national affordability benchmarks. The setting is car-dependent outside the walkable downtown core.
See more original research from School Decision →