The top reported proficiency rate is 95% in Social studies. The lowest is 53% in Science.
Original Research by School Decision on Cazenovia Middle School
Cazenovia Middle School serves students in grades five through seven in a small historic village at the south end of Cazenovia Lake, within reach of Syracuse. The school sits with the district's high school on Emory Avenue, close to the village center and its mix of walkable downtown life, civic anchors like the public library and parks, and a set of small employers in education, hospitality, and local food and beverage businesses. The community is anchored by a compact downtown with significant historic architecture and a farmers market that draws residents from across the region, though the setting is car-dependent outside the village core.
The school carries a student body that is predominantly white, with a quarter of students identifying as Hispanic or multiracial. About a third of the enrollment qualifies for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting moderate economic diversity within an otherwise affluent district. The school sits within a district that has weathered repeated budget rejections over tax-cap conflicts, a sign of fiscal strain from rising costs meeting limited state aid, though voters have ultimately approved revised budgets at lower levy increases. That backdrop shapes what schools can resource, though the district did complete a major athletic facilities project in October 2024 after voter approval in 2022, adding synthetic turf fields and track infrastructure that families focused on athletics will notice.
On state assessments, the school shows a profile of modest proficiency. In mathematics across all tested grades, proficiency stands at close to two-thirds overall, with Grade Six slightly ahead and Grades Five and Seven running a few percentage points lower. English language arts is weaker, ranging from just above half proficiency in Grade Five to near two-thirds in Grade Six, with Grade Seven falling back to about half. Science proficiency in Grade Five sits near half as well. These results place the school in the top quartile of districts across Madison County on overall proficiency, a meaningful position that reflects strong relative standing even where the absolute numbers show room for student growth. Participation rates on the state tests are solid, ranging from high eighties to mid-nineties percent across grades and subjects, suggesting consistent assessment administration.
The school has limited publicly reported program data available; information on course offerings, special-education or English-learner populations, and staffing was not present in the data. A parent may want to reach out to the school directly to understand what electives, supports, or specialized instruction are available, especially if a child has particular learning needs or academic interests.
The community itself is in transition. Cazenovia College, a significant local employer and cultural anchor, closed in mid-2023, and its former campus is now being redeveloped by a local investor group into housing and office space aimed at remote-working professionals over a multi-year timeline. Madison County has also relocated employees into downtown buildings as part of that deal. That redevelopment, combined with the district's recent athletic upgrades and the establishment of a free full-day pre-kindergarten program, signals ongoing investment in the schools, though the district's tax-cap battles and below-average state aid point to families shouldering more of the cost than districts in less affluent areas.
For a family considering whether this school is a fit, the profile suggests a community-centered, small-scale setting with decent relative academic standing, modest but real performance challenges in language arts and science, and a district actively working through fiscal constraints. The village itself offers a walkable, historic downtown with public amenities and a strong sense of place, paired with a car-dependent landscape once away from the core. Athletic facilities and outdoor recreation are strengths. A parent working through school choice or considering a move would benefit from visiting the school, asking about English-learner and special-education services, and understanding what extracurricular and elective depth exists, since that data is not publicly available here.
See more original research from School Decision →