Original Research by School Decision on May Moore Primary School
May Moore Primary School serves pre-kindergarten through second grade in Deer Park, a blue-collar residential hamlet on Long Island's commercial strip. The school enrolls about that many students across a quiet and diverse peer group.
The enrollment reflects the demographic composition of the hamlet. The student body is roughly evenly split between Hispanic, white, Asian, and Black students, with smaller populations of other backgrounds. About a substantial share of the enrolled students qualify for free or reduced price lunch, indicating that the school draws families across a range of economic circumstances. The school is particularly visible in the community: Deer Park residents display school-pride lawn signs in their midcentury suburban subdivisions, suggesting the schools hold local standing.
May Moore is part of the Deer Park Union Free School District, which extends across a residential and commercial area of western Suffolk County. The district's 2025-26 budget was approved by voters and includes infrastructure work: the Board of Education authorized capital projects in 2022 that included security upgrades at the high school and building improvements at the middle school, changes that affect school conditions and safety protocols across the system. The district's property tax rate has grown modestly year over year, a pattern families in the area should know about as a factor in local housing costs.
Academic proficiency and progress data for the school were not available through the data sources accessed. Because May Moore serves only early elementary grades, state testing does not apply to its instruction, and no graduation rate or other secondary-level metrics exist. For a parent evaluating this school, understanding how well it prepares students for elementary advancement would require a conversation with the school itself about early literacy and numeracy outcomes and classroom practice.
The school sits in Deer Park proper, a hamlet without a strong walkable downtown. Daily life is car-oriented, organized around Deer Park Avenue and its commercial corridor of strip malls, chain restaurants, and the nearby Tanger Outlets. The neighborhood surrounding the school is residential and stable. A public library serves the community with free internet and youth programming, and the LIRR station nearby offers commuter rail access. The town is undertaking a revitalization effort aimed at improving walkability and strengthening its commercial corridors, though those changes are still in early stages.
Housing in the area is moderately valued. Homes in the 11729 zip code are priced at the lower to middle end of the Long Island market, and rents are substantially less than the cost of home ownership. The market has seen modest inventory growth recently, and days on market have shortened. Families moving to the area tend to be oriented toward car-based commuting rather than walkable neighborhoods, and the schools serve that residential base.
For families seeking a small primary school in a stable, mixed-income residential setting with active community engagement, May Moore is a regular public school option in a district that maintains its buildings and invests in safety upgrades. The lack of published academic data for early grades is not unusual for schools serving these ages, but a parent may want to speak directly with the school about how it measures and supports early literacy and math skills.
See more original research from School Decision →