The top reported proficiency rate is 98% in Science. The lowest is 32% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Connetquot Elementary School
Connetquot Elementary School serves students from pre-kindergarten through second grade in Islip Terrace, a modest, family-oriented residential hamlet on Long Island's South Shore. The school sits within the East Islip Union Free School District, which also covers East Islip, Great River, and parts of the surrounding area. The hamlet itself is quiet and car-dependent, dominated by mid-20th-century single-family homes on compact lots, with most shopping and dining concentrated on Carleton Avenue or just over the border in neighboring East Islip.
The school enrolls a diverse student body of roughly equal-sized cohorts across its three grade levels. A substantial share of families qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, and the student body reflects the ethnic diversity of Long Island's South Shore, with roughly equal numbers of white and Hispanic students, a smaller Asian population, and other groups represented. This demographic composition is representative of the broader East Islip district.
The data available for this school is limited to state testing results from 2013-2014 and earlier, which is now over a decade old. Those historical results showed mixed performance across subjects. In English language arts, proficiency rates ranged from the high twenties to high thirties across tested grades. Mathematics proficiency rates were in the thirties to low forties. Science testing showed notably higher proficiency, in the high nineties for the single tested grade. The school's overall proficiency index, computed from these older results, sits above the midpoint when compared against the other districts in Suffolk County, though the age of this data means it does not reflect current classroom performance or instructional changes. Because the school serves only grades pre-K through two, it does not administer the full suite of state tests that older grades receive, which is why test data is sparse and dated; early elementary schools in New York are largely assessed through classroom observation and local measures rather than state exams.
More recent academic information, enrollment trends, staff composition, special education services, English learner supports, and current program offerings were not available in the data provided, so a fuller picture of the school's day-to-day instructional approach cannot be drawn here. A parent interested in understanding how the school currently teaches, what its staff looks like, and how it serves students with learning differences or language needs would benefit from contacting the school directly or reviewing any materials the district publishes.
The broader district context offers some useful anchors. The East Islip Union Free School District has consistently passed annual budgets with modest tax increases, signaling stable financing. In 2023, the district was required to retire its longtime 'Redmen' mascot after New York State banned Native American mascots in public schools, a change with visible effects on school branding and identity that families may notice. In May 2025, voters approved changes to student transportation policy, including new ridership eligibility rules, a practical shift that may affect which children qualify for busing.
Islip Terrace itself has seen modest population stability and recent growth in rental housing, which has brought some demographic change to an area long anchored by single-family homes. The Long Island Rail Road's Islip station is a couple of miles away, offering commuters a path to Manhattan. The hamlet has its own fire department and benefits from nearby parks, including Beaver Dam Park and Connetquot River State Park Preserve, where families can access outdoor recreation. The East Islip Public Library serves the area as a shared resource.
Housing values in the area have been stable with gradual appreciation, and the broader county market shows supply and demand in relative balance. For families considering a move to this area, the school fits within a quiet, family-centered community with straightforward suburban living. The available test data is too dated to speak to current academic standing, so prospective families would want to visit, speak with current families, and ask the school about its recent results and instructional priorities.
See more original research from School Decision →