The top reported proficiency rate is 100% in Social studies. The lowest is 30% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Edinburg Common School
Edinburg Common School serves pre-kindergarten through sixth grade in a sparsely populated rural town on the shores of Great Sacandaga Lake in the Adirondack Park. The school enrollment is small, with just a handful of students at each grade level. This is a place where a parent considers not just academics but also what it means to send their child to one of the region's smallest schools, in a town with deep roots in logging and seasonal tourism.
The school's academic results show uneven proficiency. In third grade mathematics, about three-fifths of students met or exceeded the state standard. By fourth grade, that dropped to about two-fifths. In English language arts, proficiency is lower still: one-fifth of third graders and two-fifths of fourth graders scored at proficient levels. Testing data for fifth and sixth grades were suppressed, which New York does when grade cohorts are very small, so a complete picture is not available. Against other districts in Saratoga County, Edinburg's overall proficiency index sits below the midpoint. The school participated fully in state testing, so absences were not a factor in these results. A parent may want to look into further with the school how it addresses the gaps seen in third and fourth grade, and what support structures exist for students who fall below proficient.
The student body is predominantly white, with a small presence of Hispanic and multiracial students. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic realities of a small rural community where many families have modest means. Special education and English learner enrollment data were not available. The school is not a Title I school, which is a federal designation tied to poverty concentration; this absence likely reflects the school's small size and the way those funding formulas work in sparsely populated areas rather than the absence of economic need.
Edinburg is a town of very few people spread across Adirondack woodlands and split by the lake. Most residents own their homes, and many are retirees or seasonal visitors. Home values in the area track modestly above the national benchmark but well below the New York state median. The economy turns on outdoor recreation, logging, and service to seasonal residents. There are no large employers, and residents generally commute out of town for work. Civic life centers on a small historic hamlet with a museum in a restored one-room schoolhouse, a covered bridge, war memorial, and the lake itself, where boating, fishing, and winter sports anchor the year.
Students in grades seven and above leave Edinburg for school because the district operates only this one building. The district's secondary students are tuitioned to neighboring Northville, so a family here must be prepared for that transition. The school sits in isolation from the economic and social anchors of larger towns. A family choosing Edinburg Common School chooses a very small, rural setting where their child will be known deeply by staff and peers, where outdoor life and self-reliance are woven into the local culture, and where academic support depends heavily on the resources a small district can muster. The lower proficiency rates visible in the tested grades deserve careful conversation with school leaders about how reading and mathematics instruction are structured and what happens for students who are not keeping pace.
See more original research from School Decision →