The top reported proficiency rate is 56% in Math. The lowest is 46% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Forestville Central High School
Forestville Central High School serves grades seven through twelve in a small, rural hamlet in northeastern Chautauqua County, about a short drive southwest of Buffalo. The school draws students from Forestville and parts of five surrounding towns in a largely agricultural and wine-country setting. This is a small school, with enrollment spread across six grades, and it sits within the physical fabric of the village rather than on a removed campus, making it part of the local Main Street landscape.
The school's recent state test results show mixed performance. In seventh-grade math, about two-thirds of students reached proficiency, a relatively solid showing. Eighth-grade math performed more weakly, with roughly four in ten students proficient. English language arts results tracked lower: in seventh grade, fewer than half reached proficiency, and in eighth grade the rate was similar. Science proficiency in eighth grade fell in the middle range, above the math and ELA floors but below the seventh-grade math performance. Testing participation rates were uneven, particularly in seventh grade where roughly six in ten students participated; eighth-grade participation was stronger. Across tested grades and subjects, the school's overall proficiency index places it above the midpoint among the county's districts, a meaningful distinction in a rural area where many schools cluster at lower performance levels.
The school does not report a four-year graduation rate or chronic absenteeism data, so those dimensions are not available to assess. State testing covers only through grade eight, leaving no public results for the high school grades served.
The student body is predominantly white, with a small Hispanic enrollment and even smaller representation of other groups. About a third of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, indicating mixed economic circumstances within the school community. The school has no reported special education or English learner counts in the available data, a gap that makes it hard to understand the full scope of student needs.
The district itself is undergoing sustained physical change. Voters approved a major capital improvement project in 2024, the first substantial building work in years, aimed at facility upgrades across the district with no immediate tax increase at that time. In 2025, the district pursued a second major referendum for a Clean Green Energy Project addition, bringing the combined total upgrades to well over what either project alone would cost, yet still structured to avoid additional tax impact through grants and state aid. This represents a multi-year overhaul of school buildings, a commitment parents weigh when considering a school's long-term physical environment.
After holding the line on taxes for two consecutive years through use of pandemic-era state and federal aid, the district has resumed raising the school tax levy as that aid has expired and the fund balance could no longer sustain no-growth budgets. The levy increases have been modest in the low single-digit percentage range in recent years, a shift families in the area have faced. The property tax outlook for homebuyers entering the district is one of renewed annual increases after a temporary reprieve.
Forestville itself is a quiet hamlet with flat-to-declining population over the past decades, though it faced acute disruption in July 2024 when an EF-1 tornado damaged many homes along Prospect Road. State emergency assistance was announced for recovery, and county officials identified Forestville among communities to be rebuilt, a backdrop that shapes the current moment in the community. The surrounding region offers limited fixed-route public transit; families rely on car travel via the State Thruway, U.S. Route 20, and state routes. Civic anchors include town recreation facilities, churches, the Forestville Fire Department, and a branch library in nearby Silver Creek.
Housing in the Chautauqua County zip code where Forestville sits is modestly priced relative to state and national benchmarks, with median home values roughly one-half the state average. Home listings in the county have grown in availability and supply in recent months, and prices have declined slightly year over year, reflective of broader rural housing dynamics in the region. The mortgage landscape carries current rates in the mid-six-percent range, making entry-level homes achievable for families earning area median income, though the wider economic context includes modest unemployment and relatively stable household income at the national level.
A parent considering Forestville Central High School should understand it as a small, community-embedded school serving a rural area in transition. The middle-grade state test results sit above many county peers despite lower absolute proficiency levels, a strength that reflects the school's position in a challenging testing landscape. The high school grades are not assessed at the state level, so college readiness and academic pathways in the upper grades are not captured in the public data available. The district is making substantial capital investments in facilities, a forward-looking commitment that may appeal to families planning to stay in the area for several years. Property taxes are climbing again after a temporary pause, a cost that should factor into housing affordability calculations. The community itself is small, quiet, and rooted in agriculture and small manufacturing, offering a low-cost, low-density, family-oriented setting without the amenities or transit access of larger towns.
See more original research from School Decision →