The top reported proficiency rate is 94% in Science. The lowest is 42% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Harold O Brumsted Elementary School
Harold O. Brumsted Elementary School sits on Canada Street in the small hamlet of Holland, in the rural southeastern corner of Erie County, about a half-hour southeast of Buffalo. The school serves pre-kindergarten through fourth grade as part of Holland Central School District, and it occupies a campus that locals have long described as the hub of community life. The junior-senior high school is directly next door, which makes the district's footprint unusually concentrated for a rural setting.
The school is small even by rural standards, enrolling a modest number of students across its grade levels. The student body is predominantly white, with very little demographic diversity. A meaningful share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, though the rate is not particularly high compared to many New York schools. Data on English learners and students with IEPs was not available in the records reviewed.
State testing results from the most recent year cover third and fourth grades in English language arts and math, since PreK through second grade are not tested under New York's assessment system. In third-grade ELA, more than half of students scored at the proficient level or above, which is a reasonably solid result. Third-grade math was somewhat lower, with roughly half of tested students reaching proficiency. Fourth grade showed a steeper drop in both subjects, with well under half of students scoring proficient in either ELA or math. Parents curious about what is driving the fourth-grade gap, and whether instructional supports are in place to address it, would be worth raising that question directly with the school. On the positive side, an older fourth-grade science assessment showed a very strong result, with nearly all students reaching proficiency, though that data is from an earlier school year and reflects a different cohort.
Placed against districts across Erie County, the school's overall proficiency index sits above the midpoint among the county's districts, which is a meaningful position in a county that includes both high-performing suburban systems and lower-performing urban ones.
Participation in testing was near-universal, which means the results reflect the full enrolled population rather than a selected group, and there is nothing to discount on that front.
Multi-year trend data was not available in a form that allows a clean before-and-after comparison, so whether performance has been improving, declining, or holding steady cannot be assessed here.
The community itself is rural and deliberately slow-paced. Holland has a small commercial center along Main Street in the hamlet, with a coffee shop, a restaurant, antique stores, and basic services, but daily needs beyond that require a drive to nearby Springville or Yorkshire. The surrounding landscape is farmland, wooded roads, and residential privacy. Housing values in the zip code run below both the New York state benchmark and the national benchmark, and the Erie County market as a whole has seen a meaningful uptick in active listings recently. For families buying into the district, the local housing market offers relative affordability compared to the broader state.
On the facilities side, Holland Central voters approved a capital improvement project in late 2024 covering repairs and upgrades across all three school buildings, including building controls, a new playground, and roof and boiler work. Publicly reported accounts indicate the project is substantially funded through state building aid, with no tax increase required. That followed a prior, larger capital proposal that voters had strongly rejected. The approved project represents a more targeted investment, and families with children at Brumsted can expect some physical improvements to the district's buildings in the coming years.
Program information for the elementary school specifically was not available in the data reviewed, so the full picture of enrichment offerings, intervention services, and extracurricular access at the Brumsted level is a gap worth exploring directly with the school.
Holland is a community where generational roots run deep and the school sits at its center. For a family drawn to a small, rural district with a close-knit character, modest housing costs, and test results that land above the county midpoint, the fit is clear. For families who want demographic diversity, a dense commercial environment, or richer transparency around programs and support services, those are honest limitations this setting carries.
See more original research from School Decision →