The top reported proficiency rate is 85% in Social studies. The lowest is 29% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Montgomery C Smith Elementary School
Montgomery C. Smith Elementary School sits on Harry Howard Avenue in Hudson, a small Hudson Valley city where the school district's campuses overlook the river, about half a mile from the historic Warren Street commercial corridor. Hudson itself is compact and walkable, built on a grid of 19th-century residential blocks, with a downtown anchored by an independent business culture, a year-round arts scene, and direct Amtrak access to New York City. Columbia Memorial Health is the area's largest employer; the district itself is a notable employer in the local economy.
Smith serves prekindergarten through fifth grade, making it the entry point for families in the Hudson City School District. Enrollment is sizable for a single elementary building. The student body is racially and ethnically mixed: white students make up the largest share, with Hispanic, Black, and multiracial students each representing meaningful portions of enrollment, and a smaller Asian population. A clear majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic profile of the surrounding city.
State test results, measured on the New York State Testing Program for grades three through five, tell a candid story. In ELA, third graders showed the strongest performance among tested grades, with roughly four in ten reaching proficiency, but fourth and fifth grade results were lower. Math proficiency tracked similarly, with third and fourth grade results comparable to each other and fifth grade lower still. Science results for fifth graders were in the same range as math and ELA at that grade. Across all subjects and grades, Smith's overall proficiency index places it below the midpoint relative to districts in Columbia County. These are factual descriptions of where students are currently testing; a parent who wants to understand what the school is doing in response should read on.
That context matters here. The Hudson City School District holds a New York State designation as a Target District, which requires a Comprehensive Improvement Plan. Publicly reported district communications indicate the plan specifically names Montgomery C. Smith Elementary, including a focus on improving outcomes for Hispanic students. Beginning in the 2024-25 school year, the district launched a curriculum overhaul under a new Executive Director for Teaching and Learning, adopted the Rubicon Atlas curriculum-mapping system to align instruction with state standards, and grounded the effort in a structured school-improvement framework. This is active, documented reform work, not a passive situation. A parent may want to ask the school directly about how improvement efforts are showing up in classrooms and what supports are in place for students who are behind grade level.
On the facilities side, voters approved a capital project in May 2025 that funds improvements at every building in the district, including roofing, exterior doors, gym acoustics, and other physical upgrades. The district publicly stated the project would not increase local school taxes. Separately, the 2025-26 operating budget passed with a modest tax levy increase and no staff reductions or program cuts, according to publicly reported district statements.
The housing market surrounding the school runs well above national median home values, with prices that have continued to rise. Rents in the area are also elevated, with rent-to-income ratios that create real affordability pressure. Hudson has been designated a Pro-Housing Community and has active mixed-income development underway in the Depot District. The city also voted in late 2025 to sell a former elementary school building to a developer for conversion to affordable senior housing. Families weighing the area should expect a competitive purchase market and rising rents, with some relief efforts at the planning stage.
No data was available on chronic absenteeism or special-populations rates such as students with IEPs or English learners, gaps worth asking about directly given the district's improvement focus. No graduation rate applies here because the school serves only elementary grades. Trend data across multiple years was not available in a form that could be reported.
Smith is the place where a Hudson City district family begins. The academics need strengthening and the district knows it. The community around the school is textured, diverse, and in motion.
See more original research from School Decision →