The top reported proficiency rate is 59% in Science. The lowest is 32% in Math.
Original Research by School Decision on Carlyle C Ring Elementary School
Carlyle C Ring Elementary serves the early grades (pre-K through fourth grade) in Jamestown, a postindustrial city in Chautauqua County in New York's Southern Tier. The school's enrollment is modest for its grade band, drawn from a densely residential urban area where a substantial majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch. The enrollment is nearly evenly split between White and Hispanic students, with smaller numbers of multiracial and other students.
The school sits in a place where housing is affordable: rental costs and home values in the Jamestown area are well below state and national benchmarks, which means the neighborhood remains accessible to families on modest incomes but also reflects the city's postindustrial context and long-term population decline. The downtown core is compact and historically intact, with active walkable streets, though some corridors beyond the center feel less welcoming on foot. Manufacturing and health services anchor local employment.
On state testing, Carlyle C Ring's proficiency rates are notably low. In math and English language arts for the tested grades (3 and 4), performance falls in the bottom quartile among Chautauqua County's districts. Third-grade math proficiency sits below one-third; fourth-grade math just above one-third; third-grade ELA also just above one-quarter; fourth-grade ELA approaches mid-forties. These numbers indicate that fewer than half of students in the upper elementary grades are meeting grade-level standards in core academics. Science data is older (2022) and shows stronger results for fourth grade, but the more current reading and math picture suggests ongoing foundational skill gaps.
The district has made deliberate moves in response. In 2023 it adopted a new reading curriculum aligned to New York's Science of Reading initiative, with early-grade emphasis on phonemic awareness and phonics, reflecting an evidence-based shift in how foundational literacy is taught. This curriculum change is recent enough that its effects on performance are not yet visible in the testing data shown here.
The district is also in the middle of a substantial capital improvement project approved by voters in December 2023, involving work at every school building through 2027. This means the school building itself will see upgrades, though families should expect construction activity and associated disruptions over the coming years. The project does carry a modest local property-tax impact, though the district has held its operating tax levy flat in recent budgets, with voters approving budgets by strong majorities.
Starting in September 2025, all Jamestown schools will enforce a bell-to-bell restriction on personal devices (phones, smartwatches, tablets) during the instructional day, including lunch and recess. This statewide policy change becomes part of daily school life.
A parent considering Carlyle C Ring should weigh the school's low proficiency rates against the district's recent curriculum adoption in reading. The school serves a lower-income, multiethnic urban population in an affordable housing market, and it sits within a district committed to visible facility investment and voter-supported budgets. Whether the new reading curriculum begins to move test results upward will be important to monitor in coming years.
See more original research from School Decision →