The top reported proficiency rate is 84% in Science. The lowest is 46% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Abraham Lincoln Elementary School
Abraham Lincoln Elementary School serves pre-kindergarten through grade four in Jamestown, a postindustrial city in southern Chautauqua County that has been investing steadily in downtown revitalization and waterfront renewal. The school sits in a dense urban neighborhood where most families rent their homes and a large majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, a marker of economic need that shapes the school's work.
The school enrolls a small to mid-sized population for its grade band, with slightly more than half the enrollment in grades three and four where state testing occurs. The student body is predominantly white, with a meaningful Hispanic population and smaller Asian, Black, and multiracial representation. The school's peer environment reflects the city's economic fabric: economic diversity is limited, and the student composition is characteristic of Jamestown's demographic makeup.
On state assessment results, the school shows uneven performance across subjects. In mathematics, students in grade four outperform those in grade three, with a solid share reaching proficiency in grade four and a smaller share in grade three. English language arts presents a steeper challenge, particularly in grade four, where proficiency drops below half of tested students. Science results from an earlier year showed substantially stronger performance. This pattern across subjects suggests that while some learners are moving toward grade-level standards, others are not yet meeting them, and the gap is wider in reading than in math. A parent may want to look into this further with the school to understand what classroom supports exist for students still building proficiency.
Within Chautauqua County's school districts, Abraham Lincoln ranks in the top quartile for overall proficiency across tested subjects and grades, a meaningful position that reflects solid academic performance relative to regional peers. The school is not subject to Title I accountability measures, and no chronic absenteeism or graduation data apply because the school serves only early elementary grades.
Jamestown itself is a city of roughly mid-sized population in decline, a former furniture and textile center now anchored by manufacturing firms like Cummins and Truck-Lite alongside health services and public institutions. The downtown, centered on North Main and Third Streets, retains an intact historic core with brick streets and a National Register district of over one hundred contributing buildings. Civic life concentrates downtown: the James Prendergast Library, the CARTS transit hub, and Jamestown High School sit in the core within walking distance of one another. Recent years have brought the National Comedy Center as a riverfront anchor, new parks along the Chadakoin River, and a renovated train station. Housing is affordable compared to state benchmarks, with median home values and rents reflecting the city's economic trajectory, and the rental market has grown recently, with active listings rising.
The Jamestown City School District is in the midst of a multi-year capital improvement project approved by voters in December 2023 that will touch every school building, including Abraham Lincoln, with construction phases extending into 2027. This means families moving in should expect both facility upgrades and a cumulative property-tax effect. The district has held tax-levy growth modest in recent budgets, with voters approving the 2025-26 budget by a strong margin despite a small levy increase. In 2023 the district adopted a new K-8 reading and literacy curriculum aligned to the Science of Reading, shifting early-grades instruction toward phonemic awareness and phonics. Beginning in September 2025, all students will be unable to use personal devices during the instructional day under a statewide law, a daily change in school life worth considering.
For a family looking at Abraham Lincoln, the school offers a stable academic environment where a solid core of students reaches proficiency, particularly in math and science, within an economically diverse urban setting. The school's top-quartile regional performance is a genuine strength. At the same time, reading proficiency in grade four warrants attention and conversation with school staff about individual student pathways and interventions. The school's location in downtown Jamestown means walkable access to library and transit resources, and families should factor in both the ongoing capital construction and the modest, voter-approved tax increases over the project's life.
See more original research from School Decision →