The top reported proficiency rate is 71% in Science. The lowest is 15% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Samuel G Love Elementary School
Samuel G Love Elementary serves prekindergarten through fourth grade in Jamestown, New York, a postindustrial city on the Southern Tier that has been reinvesting in its downtown and riverfront. The school sits in an urban setting with dense residential streets and is the neighborhood school for families in the city proper.
The enrollment is small to moderate for an early-elementary building. A substantial share of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic context of Jamestown, where median rental rates are modest and housing values are lower than state and national benchmarks. The student population is diverse: roughly half identify as Hispanic, white, or multiracial, with smaller shares of Black students. Data on special education and English learner enrollment rates were not available, so a parent may want to look into this further with the school.
The academic picture is a soft spot. In the most recent state testing results, proficiency rates in math and English language arts are well below state benchmarks. In grade three, proficiency in math was in the low twenties and in ELA in the low twenties as well. In grade four, proficiency dropped further, to single digits in both subjects. Science proficiency data is from an earlier year and showed a much stronger result, but the recent math and ELA results are substantially below the county median. Relative to other districts in Chautauqua County, the school's overall proficiency index places it in the bottom quartile. A parent considering Samuel G Love would be wise to ask the district directly about the drivers behind these numbers, what targeted support is in place, and whether recent curriculum or instruction changes are beginning to affect outcomes.
One relevant context is the district-wide curriculum adoption. In 2023 Jamestown adopted a structured literacy curriculum (HMH Into Reading for early grades) aligned to New York's Science of Reading framework, with an emphasis on phonemic awareness and phonics in the early grades. This is a change in instructional practice that would be new to students entering the school system, so families might reasonably ask whether they expect this to address the reading and math proficiency patterns over time.
The district also passed a major capital improvement project in December 2023 that includes work at every school building. Families should anticipate both facility upgrades and a property tax impact extending into 2027. The district has held its operating tax levy relatively flat in recent budgets, so the capital project is the primary tax change on the horizon.
Starting in the 2025-26 school year, all students in Jamestown schools are required to be phone-free during the entire instructional day, following New York's statewide Distraction-Free Schools law. This is a bell-to-bell restriction, including lunch and recess, and represents a structural change in daily school experience.
Jamestown itself is a walkable urban community with an active downtown, a restored train station, civic anchors like the Prendergast Library, and revitalized riverfront parks. Manufacturing and health services anchor employment, and the city has been investing in affordable housing and downtown revitalization after decades of population decline. For families choosing an early-elementary school, Samuel G Love offers an urban neighborhood setting with strong institutional connections and an intentional literacy focus, though the recent proficiency outcomes warrant careful conversation with school leadership about instructional progress and support systems.
See more original research from School Decision →