The top reported proficiency rate is 91% in Social studies. The lowest is 44% in English language arts.
Original Research by School Decision on Ben Franklin Elementary School
Ben Franklin Elementary School serves kindergarten through fourth grade in Buffalo, part of the Kenmore-Tonawanda Union Free School District. The school enrolls a small student body for its grade band, with a diverse peer population: just over half the enrollment is white, with substantial shares of students identifying as two or more races, Black, Hispanic, and Asian. A majority of students qualify for free or reduced-price lunch, reflecting the economic circumstances of the neighborhood.
The school's academic profile shows modest proficiency overall. In the most recent testing data, Ben Franklin's math results were evenly split between students meeting and not meeting proficiency in both third and fourth grades, while English language arts results ran somewhat lower, with fewer than half of students proficient in each tested grade. The school's science results from a few years back were stronger, with a clear majority of fourth-graders proficient. These patterns suggest uneven performance across subjects, with math roughly at the halfway mark and reading below it.
Positioned among the county's districts on an overall proficiency index, Ben Franklin sits above the midpoint. This positioning reflects the mixed results: the school is neither a standout performer nor a lagging one in the county context, but rather positioned in the middle-to-upper band of district proficiency measures. A parent evaluating this school would want to understand the specific instructional focus in reading and the steps the school is taking to boost those results.
The enrollment is stable. The school sits in one of Buffalo's historically residential neighborhoods, where the housing stock is older, with late-19th and early-20th-century wood-frame homes and rowhouses, and where many blocks have experienced some housing turnover. Within the school's attendance zone, housing values are modest and rents are similarly moderate. The area is somewhat walkable, with commercial corridors nearby and access to bus transit, though it is not as dense as downtown Buffalo's core neighborhoods.
The district itself is in transition. A major capital project completed in recent years brought facility upgrades to aging buildings district-wide. More notably, the district expanded its full-day universal pre-kindergarten program and reopened a closed elementary building to house it, making free full-day early learning available. At the same time, the district is publicly considering a significant restructuring proposal that would close some schools, reopen others, and shift grade configurations, driven by budget pressures and enrollment losses to charter and private schools. This proposal remained unresolved as of spring 2026 and could affect which school children in Ben Franklin's boundary attend. Additionally, starting in fall 2025 all students face bell-to-bell restrictions on personal devices during the school day, a statewide New York requirement now in effect.
Ben Franklin is a regular public elementary school without magnet or charter designation. It offers a traditional grade-band structure and curriculum, serving families who value neighborhood school access and public school education in a walkable urban setting. The school's modest proficiency results, paired with its above-midpoint county standing, suggest it is neither exceptional nor underperforming in isolation, but rather a typical neighborhood elementary with room for growth in reading. A parent considering this school would benefit from a direct conversation with the school about current reading initiatives and longer-term plans in light of the district's proposed restructuring.
See more original research from School Decision →